Don't Tell Mama NYC

4.2
1619 recensies
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
30 $ en minder
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.
Modern Amerikaans
Populairste tags:
  • Voor of na het theater
  • Ontspannen
  • Geschikt voor een date

Speciale aanbiedingen

New Year's Eve 4 course prixe fixe - $75

4 course meal plus a complementary flute of champagne

Algemene voorwaarden:

Geldig voor: 1 - 20 mensen

Begint op: 13 december 2018

Eindigt op: 14 december 2117

Beschikbaarheid: ma. 19:00-23:00

New Years Eve in Restaurant

4 course Prixe fixe meal for $55

Algemene voorwaarden:

Geldig voor: 1 - 20 mensen

Begint op: 13 december 2018

Eindigt op: 14 december 2117

Beschikbaarheid: ma.-di. 16:00-19:00

Christmas Eve and Christmas Day- $45 Prixe Fixe

4 course meal

Algemene voorwaarden:

Geldig voor: 1 - 20 mensen

Begint op: 13 december 2018

Eindigt op: 14 december 2117

Beschikbaarheid: ma.-di. 16:00-22:45

Prixe Fixe Menu - $35

3 course meal. appetizer, entree and dessert

Algemene voorwaarden:

Geldig voor: 1 - 20 mensen

Begint op: 13 december 2018

Eindigt op: 14 december 2117

Beschikbaarheid: vr.-za. 16:00-23:00

Prixe Fixe Menu- $32

3 course meal. appetizer, entree and dessert

Algemene voorwaarden:

Geldig voor: 1 - 20 mensen

Begint op: 13 december 2018

Eindigt op: 14 december 2117

Beschikbaarheid: zo.-do. 16:00-23:00

Verhoog uw puntenaantal direct met diner beloningen

Bekijk de beschikbaarheid van tafels met bonuspunten

Mon - Thu 16:00 - 17:00

Wat 1619 mensen zeggen
Algehele beoordelingen en recensies
Alleen gasten die bij dit restaurant hebben gegeten, kunnen recensies schrijven
4.2op basis van recente beoordelingen
4.1
eten
4.5
bediening
4.3
sfeer
4.1
prijs-kwaliteit
Geluid · Redelijk rustig
90% van de mensen zouden dit aan hun vrienden aanbevelen
5
4
3
2
1
Sorteer op
Nieuwste
Filters
B
Alabama
3 recensies
5 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 5sfeer 3

Fun gathering with friends. Good food and wine. Outstanding service! Highly recommend.

Melden
Nuttig
BF
3 recensies
7 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Place is small but quaint and pleasant. Food, drinks, and service were excellent. Recommend for pre-theater or any occasion as long as group is 4 or less.

Melden
Nuttig
MK
73 recensies
Gegeten op 7 februari 2019
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 4sfeer 3

My meal was satisfactory, if pricey. The service was warm and also satisfactory. The location is perfect for pre-theatre dining.

However, I'm currently debating with Open Table because I should've been credited with 1000 points (as was the offer when I made my online reservation), but only got 100 points. I don't know why this discrepancy happened, but it has tarnished my view of the restaurant, as well as of Open Table...

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 7 februari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

Great service! Lamb was delicious, steak was more cooked than I ordered it but still tasty.

Melden
Nuttig
PC
43 recensies
Gegeten op 3 februari 2019
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 4sfeer 4

I came here for an early dinner between the Harry Potter plays on Sunday, and was seated promptly although I arrived a little early for my reservation. I had the mixed salad, BBQ spare rib and the lemon meringue pie with coffee. Food was fine and the service was very professional. Since only 1 or 2 other tables were occupied at time, the place was quiet. This is a handy place for bite if you are attending the theatre nearby.

Melden
Nuttig
F
8 recensies
Gegeten op 27 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 3bediening 4sfeer 5

We had a wonderful time again at Don’t Tell Mama. My salmon portion was very small. I felt they should have picked a bigger piece or maybe even combined 2 pieces since they were so small.
But it was delicious. Our waiter was great. We had a lovely dinner.

Melden
Nuttig
KS
30 recensies
Gegeten op 26 januari 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

Warm, very busy atmosphere. Waiter was nice but had lot of responsibilities to deal with. Food was very tasty, presented nicely and arrived warm! Would return!

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 26 januari 2019
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 4sfeer 2

The food was great — the service was okay — it was very noisy, difficult to have normal conversation. The piano bar was awesome....

I would come again.

Melden
Nuttig
T
Miami / Zuidoos
25 recensies
Gegeten op 24 januari 2019
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 4sfeer 3

Great location right off Broadway. A fun atmosphere, good service and good food. Given the choices of restaurants in the area, I would probably not return and would try somewhere new.

Melden
Nuttig
AJ
43 recensies
Gegeten op 23 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

We loved dinner at Don't Tell Mama. My salad and Shrimp Scampi were outstanding, and there were ample wine choices -- we loved the pinot noir we ended up with. Service was friendly and prompt. We would definitely go back.

Melden
Nuttig
J
27 recensies
Gegeten op 22 januari 2019
Algeheel 1eten 2bediening 5sfeer 1

The food was just okay and the portions were small. The best part of the meal was dessert.
It is a small room and there was a family of 14 with small children. The noise level was impossible and we ate as fast as we could to get out of there. I understand that is not the fault of the restaurant but they should let patrons know when they book that kind of group. Other than that group and two tables it was empty. I will not be returning. The staff was very nice but could not overcome the noise and the food.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 20 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 4

The service was great, as we were running late before a show and needed to rush a little bit! Our server made sure everything came out quickly, without feeling rushed, and we still made it to the theater with plenty of time to spare! The food was tasty, the restaurant was quiet, especially for a Sunday night. Overall, great experience

Melden
Nuttig
D
4 recensies
Gegeten op 20 januari 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

Thoroughly enjoyed our experience for four at Don't Tell Mama NYC. Duck with couscous was delicious! Drinks were bigger and cheaper in restaurant than at bar. Wait in piano lounge was cramped, but nice music. Restaurant is small, so seating is close. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. Overall, nice evening.

Melden
Nuttig
JK
1 recensie
Gegeten op 20 januari 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 5sfeer 4

Excellent food and service! Hidden gem for theatre-goers.

Melden
Nuttig
LS
Los Angeles
19 recensies
Gegeten op 20 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

I would eat here every night if i could. Food was amazing. I would have never found it, if not for open table. Everything was awesome!!

Melden
Nuttig
j
Washington, D.C
37 recensies
Gegeten op 19 januari 2019
Algeheel 3eten 4bediening 2sfeer 3

The food was fine but the service and speed were pretty bad. We had to ask for everything. From water, to bread, to another drink. It was very frustrating. It appeared they were understaffed. We made our reservation for 6 and I had to take my dessert to go since we had an 8:00 show.
My salmon was tasty. The lamb chops were very good too. You just have to be prepared to wait or give yourself a lot of extra time.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 18 januari 2019
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 5sfeer 4

We had a great server. Service was very prompt. Food was good, but nothing special.

Melden
Nuttig
SK
3 recensies
Gegeten op 16 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Service was excellent! Beef short ribs were delicious. Would go again in a heartbeat.

Melden
Nuttig
LG
Orange County
8 recensies
Gegeten op 13 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Thoroughly enjoyed a delicious meal in the restaurant section - which assured us of a great seat in the adjoining piano bar where the extremely talented pianist, Paddy, accompanied the wait staff who would break into song and/or take the mic after 9 pm. 'had an absolutely wonderful evening in NYC's theater district.

Melden
Nuttig
IL
Atlantic City /
1 recensie
Gegeten op 12 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

We went for the first time based off the recommendation of a friend and absolutely LOVED it. The ambiance was great, the food and drinks were delicious and then our dessert was phenomenal. We each ordered something different so we could taste the others (4 in all) especially the Chocolate Prada and we thoroughly enjoyed each of them. The cost was also reasonable for the quality we received.

Melden
Nuttig
c
165 recensies
Gegeten op 12 januari 2019
Algeheel 4eten 3bediening 4sfeer 4

We went to a cabaret performance and wanted to stay in same venue and the restaurant had a nice varied menu so we stayed and all was fine and convenient

Melden
Nuttig
LS
1 recensie
Gegeten op 8 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Two of us stopped in pre theater in January. We had been here once before in the summer and every table was taken plus a long wait. This time we found it pleasantly uncrowded. The food was delicious and the service spot on. We were not rushed out at all (probably due to it being a slow night, but still we appreciated it). As native New Yorkers we feel we found a gem and would return again.

Melden
Nuttig
SL
26 recensies
Gegeten op 6 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

I love Don't Tell Moma! It's the place place on Restaurant Row and love all the regular customers who have been coming back for years.

Melden
Nuttig
d
Washington, D.C
18 recensies
Gegeten op 5 januari 2019
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 5sfeer 4

Location super convenient being in theatre district. Service was terrific, very attentive and the drinks and food arrived in timely manner. Quality of food just ok. Chicken over cooked, dry. Ravioli was tasty but overpowered by the sauce.

Melden
Nuttig
T
48 recensies
Gegeten op 5 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

I’m a theater goer. I always have dinner before any show. This weekend I was attending two plays. I was trying not to spend my average of a $100.00 per meal. I have to say that DON’T TELL MOMA did not disappoint. I had the lamb chops and my friend had the duck w/couscous. I really enjoyed the lamb chops. They also split a salad for us, which was great. The winner of the evening was the cream brûlée’s! Made fresh and obviously not sitting in the refrigerator all day waiting to be torched, the custard was light and the glaze was thin! The coffee was great also! I would go back again! I met my cost at way below $100.00.

Melden
Nuttig
JW
1 recensie
Gegeten op 5 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Excellent as always! The food, service, and ambiance are superb. The combination of locals and tourists, the quality of the food, and the entertainment next door make Don't Tell Mama part of our NYC plans on every trip.

Melden
Nuttig
G
8 recensies
Gegeten op 1 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

We were a family visiting from Edinburgh and couldn’t have chosen a better venue for New Years. Food was good, service was good but to top all of that we enjoyed the singers / piano player and the regulars that made it overall a very enjoyable night.

It was raining outside and the ball drop became a no. As said couldn’t have chosen a better venue. Thanks guys n gals and all the best for the future.

Melden
Nuttig
RA
41 recensies
Gegeten op 30 december 2018
Algeheel 3eten 4bediening 5sfeer 4

Nice place good food and the piano player nice.

Melden
Nuttig
N
Washington, D.C
5 recensies
Gegeten op 30 december 2018
Algeheel 4eten 3bediening 3sfeer 3

Nice place. On the small side. Good food. Good service and a good value.

Melden
Nuttig
D
1 recensie
Gegeten op 29 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Took a chance and made reservations after a show and was pleasantly impressed by the food and the waitstaff. Will definitely return. There is a club in the rear that looks like a good time. Bathroom could be cleaned up a bit - otherwise great 👍

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 28 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

We love it here. Excellent food and excellent service. Highly recommend.

Melden
Nuttig
J
2 recensies
Gegeten op 27 december 2018
Algeheel 4eten 3bediening 4sfeer 3

Overall great restaurant. Small portions and no extra bread which would offset fish dish with no carbs. Waitress was spot on. Many choices on menu for all.

Melden
Nuttig
a
Atlanta / Georg
25 recensies
Gegeten op 25 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

First time diner. We tried the Christmas prix fixe menu $45 per person. Ordered the lamb and my partner ordered turkey breast. Both were delicious. Dessert was chocolate mousse cake. Yum. One feedback was the Moscow mule wasn’t served in a copper mug like I used to. Other than that great dining experience.

Melden
Nuttig
CH
1 recensie
Gegeten op 25 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Our waiter Ryan was fantastic!! He was kind, efficient, patient (one of our party was not so nice). I loved the food, the atmosphere everything about the restaurant. Food was great, drinks were great !!! We had a great Christmas Dinner.

Melden
Nuttig
RT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 25 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

We had Christmas Day dinner at Dont Tell Mama, the food was outstanding, the team crewing for the day were amazing and nothing was too much trouble and the whole thing including a lot of drinks and a 4 course meal for two (that we couldn’t finish, SOOOO much food) was under $150.

We’ve also been to Don’t Tell Mama for work events and dinners on a normal evening and the shows are amazing, funny, talented and completely worth losing an evening too.

Can’t recommend this place enough for anything and everything you want to do.

Melden
Nuttig
K
1 recensie
Gegeten op 25 december 2018
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 3sfeer 4

Food was okay for the price. The fish and steak all came out over cooked although My bf said his lamp chops were very good. Probably wouldn’t come back here.

Melden
Nuttig
JN
1 recensie
Gegeten op 24 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

Very good food and excellent, friendly service in a nice location. Highly recommended!

Melden
Nuttig
CP
8 recensies
Gegeten op 23 december 2018
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 4sfeer 4

Ordered the duck for dinner. By 5am the next morning I was sick as can be and spent the entire day sick in the bathroom.

Melden
Nuttig
KM
1 recensie
Gegeten op 20 december 2018
Algeheel 4eten 3bediening 4sfeer 2

I was disappointed in the food...the menu looked great, lots of offerings, but my meal was without taste and looking at the rest of the meals at our table of 10, nothing looked very appetizing . As a family we had a great time, but I wouldn't go there again.

Melden
Nuttig
NC
38 recensies
Gegeten op 19 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Wonderful place in the heart of Restaurant Row. The service is attentive and very pleasant, delicious selection of fresh fish, always wonderfully prepared, and the GM of this place came over and asked how the table was doing several times. Really enjoyed the personal touches through out the evening, and I cannot recommend this place enough. I'll always return when i'm around this neighborhood. They're also very aware of of pre and post theatre needs if you come here before a show or after.

Melden
Nuttig
1
2
3
41