Butcher and Banker NYC

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-quarterCreated with Sketch.
4.4
icon/ic_reviewCreated with Sketch.
463 Reviews
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
van 31 $ tot 50 $
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.
Steakhouse
Populairste tags:
  • Geschikt voor een date
  • Speciale gelegenheid
  • Romantisch

Speciale aanbiedingen

Verhoog uw puntenaantal direct met diner beloningen

Bekijk de beschikbaarheid van tafels met bonuspunten

Daily 16:00 - 23:00

Wat 463 mensen zeggen
Algehele beoordelingen en recensies
Alleen gasten die bij dit restaurant hebben gegeten, kunnen recensies schrijven
4.4op basis van recente beoordelingen
4.4
eten
4.5
bediening
4.4
sfeer
4.0
prijs-kwaliteit
Geluid · Stil
94% van de mensen zouden dit aan hun vrienden aanbevelen
5
4
3
2
1
Sorteer op
Filters
LC
San Francisco
2 recensies
3 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 3sfeer 5

Lovely experience in the bar/restaurant.
Wish the staff had informed us that the restaurant was closing prior to bringing us our check given that we wanted one more round of drinks.
Overall good.

Melden
Nuttig
DS
1 recensie
6 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Yana mixes some great cocktails and the food was good and plentiful! We were talked into the bacon and did not regret it for one second!!

Melden
Nuttig
EF
1 recensie
7 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

Fantastic space. Good food. Attentive service. Will visit again.

Melden
Nuttig
T
1 recensie
Gegeten op 12 juni 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Service and food were outstanding. I will go back next time in town

Melden
Nuttig
OT
Kent
2 recensies
Gegeten op 9 juni 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great service, good food.

Melden
Nuttig
AB
1 recensie
Gegeten op 4 juni 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

My wife and I were looking for a good restaurant to celebrate/commiserate the last evening of our lovely holiday in USA and Canada before flying home the next day and, by golly, did we find it 😊 Service was great, food was grand, ambiance splendid - we had a terrific dinner and a very pleasant evening.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 2 juni 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

It was very good! It was the best meal we have had this trip! They even had sweet tea!

Melden
Nuttig
ES
1 recensie
Gegeten op 1 juni 2019
Algeheel 2eten 3bediening 1sfeer 3

Okay atmosphere-- didn't realize this was essential a "hotel restaurant." Wish the service was more attentive for the price. Requested to sit in the vault, was denied.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 1 juni 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 5sfeer 2

They shouldn’t have big parties outside of that room that fits big parties, it was so loud

Melden
Nuttig
NF
1 recensie
Gegeten op 1 juni 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

A good friend and I ate hear last Saturday prior to the Joshua Ruiz fight at MSG. I may have had a better meal in my life, But I can't remember when. The service was quick and receptive. Our waiter was outstanding and spoke with confidence of his food knowledge. This is nitpicking but a more comprehensive list of their distilled spirits would be great; i.e their list comprised their Scotch, Bourbon and Rum. Tequilla wouldve been nice to see. Also they could add a few more Bourbons above the mid range level. All and all my buddy and I have an amazing experience here and will asbolutely return.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
5 recensies
Gegeten op 29 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

Great service, intimate space, fun eating in the old bank vault.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
2 recensies
Gegeten op 23 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Loved it hshdhdjdhdhfjdjfjfndnjf

Melden
Nuttig
l
19 recensies
Gegeten op 22 mei 2019
Algeheel 3eten 2bediening 3sfeer 4

I ordered steak medium rare, and it came out medium. My friend had filet mignon and was a thin meat; usually it comes out very thick. Drinks were good; shrimp cocktail excellent. Prices a bit high for the caliber.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 22 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great place for my girlfriend’s birthday

Melden
Nuttig
MS
1 recensie
Gegeten op 21 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Juan Miguel took amazing care of my husband and me. We were in town for our wedding anniversary and chose Butcher and Banker based on a friend’s recommendation and were not disappointed! From the moment we sat down Juan Miguel was attentive and helpful. We asked for several suggestions. We were torn between oyster choices; he preferred the Blue Island and we loved them! The wine list was daunting with so many wonderful selections. He recommended the Flanagan Cabernet. It was one of the best Cabs we have ever had and paired perfectly with the delmonico we chose. After dinner, we were contemplating a digestif. He recommended the Dapper Banker, which my husband had to start the evening and enjoyed very much. We opted for a simple shot of The Balvenie Caribbean cask, but I’m sure we would have enjoyed his choice! Throughout the evening were more than looked after. We can assure you, we will be back!

Melden
Nuttig
MM
1 recensie
Gegeten op 21 mei 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

This is close to MSG so it is great for a concert or any Garden Event. Very limited on sides and apps.
We all got the Filet Steak was fine we went with 5 woman 1drink each one app 2 sides of vegies 115./ person
Not sure I would say that was worth it ....
but location location location

Melden
Nuttig
MG
5 recensies
Gegeten op 21 mei 2019
Algeheel 1eten 1bediening 3sfeer 1

There are plenty of expensive steakhouses in midtown that know how to cook a good steak unfortunately Butcher and Banker isn’t one of them.
Not only that but the staff have no clue about the menu and have a difficult time recommending items other than the porter house. Avoid this place like the plague! This is a picture of my medium cooked steak! (Rare)

Melden
Nuttig
DM
4 recensies
Gegeten op 17 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

The service, food, and ambiance were outstanding! I would definitely return. I will recommend this restaurant to family and friends.

Melden
Nuttig
SU
1 recensie
Gegeten op 15 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 3sfeer 4

If you love good beef, this is your place. Hardy portions, expertly grilled! The atmosphere was really cool and for once, in NYC, we weren't crammed in like sardines!

Melden
Nuttig
F
26 recensies
Gegeten op 13 mei 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 5

Great choice next to MSG. Cool atmosphere and well done steaks. Smoked Short Rib was fantastic

Melden
Nuttig
LB
Philadelphia /
7 recensies
Gegeten op 13 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

What a nice surprise, I read the reviews and decided to take a chance. I am glad I did. Everyone enjoyed their meals, steaks were of excellent quality. The bank vault room was a hit with our guests and it is incredibly convenient given it is right behind Penn Station.

Very pleased overall with our decision to dine here.

Melden
Nuttig
AT
12 recensies
Gegeten op 11 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

It’s in the basement, so the signal is not the best down there. Dishes were a little bit heavy, but the beef and all other ingredients are indeed with good quality.
Great dining environment and service as well!

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 10 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 4sfeer 5

The food was outstanding we had the Maryland lump crab cake for starter it was phenomenal. The steak was cooked perfectly with a nice crust on the outside and juicy in the middle. The desserts were really good also. The cocktails are really good here too.
The only bad thing I can say is that the waiter messed up our starter order and then also messed up our bill. That aside I would reccomend this place, its has a cosy feel and is also unique as its inside a bank vault.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
Orlando / Oost-
4 recensies
Gegeten op 9 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

Huge portions, which is obviously a plus however the main (which we shared between two people, which is what you are meant to do) was too much in portion size even for us and we eat alot. I didn't feel abit poorly the next day but that was likely because I forced myself to eat as much as I could. I'd recommend sharing this between 3 to 4 people. Other than that food and service was amazing

Melden
Nuttig
C
Zuidwest-Florid
4 recensies
Gegeten op 9 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Nice steakhouse near the Garden. Food was excellent and the waiter was very pleasant. A little noisy but nice atmosphere.

Melden
Nuttig
BM
1 recensie
Gegeten op 7 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Best kept secret in NYC but, the word is getting out. Food is outstanding. Service is warm and welcoming. ....And, it's a really nice place. It's the old M & T bank Vault.
It's small, cozy and fun.

Melden
Nuttig
LI
26 recensies
Gegeten op 7 mei 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

Very nice restaurant, pleasantly surprised. Met my wife for an early dinner and choose this place because it was close to Penn. The food was really good, very tasty and what you would expect from a NYC steakhouse. Our waitress was very attentive and always around. The ambiance was pretty nice, we sat in the main dining room as opposed to the vault (which is a pretty cool novelty) and tables were comfortable (they weren't on top of each other). Great find, great date night.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
3 recensies
Gegeten op 4 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Food was AMAZING! Service was also on point.

Melden
Nuttig
m
214 recensies
Gegeten op 4 mei 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

There are two separate areas, one is the vault, lined with deposit boxes and then there is the larger dining room which may be a little noisier. The vault tends to be quieter and more intimate. Service is efficient, friendly and good. The food is very good with the steaks and meat, obviously being the best choices. The wine list is good if a little on the pricey side. All in all this is a very pleasant place with good food and service, what more could one want? I think the unique atmosphere of the vault behind the hugs bank door adds something to the place.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
7 recensies
Gegeten op 4 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

Really beautiful old building! Great service.

Melden
Nuttig
D
1 recensie
Gegeten op 3 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Beautiful restaurant in a classic New York hotel called the ‘New Yorker’.
Excellent service and food!

Melden
Nuttig
HI
17 recensies
Gegeten op 3 mei 2019
Algeheel 3eten 3bediening 4sfeer 1

We had table in the vault which was very cool, but the lighting in the room was horrible. Had no ambiance at all, better for business/social occasion than for dates. Friendly service, food came out very quickly.

Melden
Nuttig
h
San Francisco
3 recensies
Gegeten op 2 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

Made a last minute reservation and got right in. Waiter gave us great advice on what to order and did not disappoint!

Melden
Nuttig
H
19 recensies
Gegeten op 30 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Chef Scott Campbell is a genius. His food is spectacular and very creative. The meal is worth every penny and it is a pricey restaurant.

Melden
Nuttig
t
2 recensies
Gegeten op 28 april 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 3

Nice food, but felt it was over priced.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 27 april 2019
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great restaurant! Great waiter... we were happy overall!

Melden
Nuttig
FD
Londen
2 recensies
Gegeten op 27 april 2019
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

It is not a tipical restaurant of an hotel. Nice design, very attentive and friendly staff, high quality of food.
Interesting wine list.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
3 recensies
Gegeten op 26 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Honestly, what a phenomenal hidden gem inside of Manhattan! I hate to give up my secret but this is too good to be selfish about. Usually when there is a cool or novel atmosphere, the food is compromised. I can confirm that my picky self of over 12 years in hospitality was blown away by the customer service, decadent food of every course, and the talent of mixology of cocktails. 2849/10 would take my parents here to flex on my Manhattan knowledge. If you can request Juan Miguel, do it!

Melden
Nuttig
GP
1 recensie
Gegeten op 26 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Impeccable service from Juan Miguel. Vibrant ambiance. Fantastic food; delicious & flavouful.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
Greensboro / Wi
1 recensie
Gegeten op 26 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Best tomahawk steak I’ve ever had.

Melden
Nuttig
1
2
3
12
null