Butcher and Banker NYC

4.3
314 recensies
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
van 31 $ tot 50 $
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.
Steakhouse
Populairste tags:
  • Geschikt voor een date
  • Speciale gelegenheid
  • Zakelijke maaltijden

Speciale aanbiedingen

Verhoog uw puntenaantal direct met diner beloningen

Bekijk de beschikbaarheid van tafels met bonuspunten

Daily 16:00 - 23:00

Wat 314 mensen zeggen
Algehele beoordelingen en recensies
Alleen gasten die bij dit restaurant hebben gegeten, kunnen recensies schrijven
4.3op basis van recente beoordelingen
4.3
eten
4.3
bediening
4.4
sfeer
3.9
prijs-kwaliteit
Geluid · Redelijk rustig
85% van de mensen zouden dit aan hun vrienden aanbevelen
5
4
3
2
1
Sorteer op
Nieuwste
Filters
OT
2 recensies
4 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Very intimate atmosphere
Upscale feel
We ate in a bank vault which was unique
Quality of the service, food, and presentation was top notch

Few blocks from MSG

Bring a special date the way I did

Melden
Nuttig
J
93 recensies
5 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 4sfeer 4

a total FABULOUS surprise! I stumbled upon it on pentacle and it turns out I know the shcef
Only discovered it as I was leaving!!
I will go back for sure

Melden
Nuttig
OT
13 recensies
6 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Cool spot! Dinner inside a bank vault. Definitely a hidden gem. A must is the bacon appetizer which was outstandingly delicious. I’m a snob about my crab cakes and these were done right. Had a burger with again bacon and I was not mad. Was stuffed and took half of it home. Seconds were sooo good! Give it a try you will be pleasantly surprised.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
2 recensies
Gegeten op 10 januari 2019
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 4sfeer 3

Great for a good meal before the Rangers game. Our waiter Tutto was excellent! Good value

Melden
Nuttig
FL
2 recensies
Gegeten op 10 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

First time customer. The waiter new the entire menu and was very professional. Food was outstanding. Definitely a new life location

Melden
Nuttig
NY
16 recensies
Gegeten op 8 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

The food is awesome. 2nd time there. Great steakhouse but the best part of this meal was the Lobster Bisque this time. My bisque had a chunk of lobster in every spoonful. AMAZING!

Melden
Nuttig
S
1 recensie
Gegeten op 7 januari 2019
Algeheel 1eten 4bediening 1sfeer 2

The waiter, when we asked whether the price for wine was per bottle or glass, and then asked to get a bottle of Malbec, he answered that it was a ‘cheap wine, that’s a comfortable price level’. He sassed the waiter that tried to refill our glasses with water as ‘Mr eager’ and ‘Mr eager over here will help you’. It was my dads 70th birthday and I sincerely regret taking him there.

Melden
Nuttig
MK
1 recensie
Gegeten op 6 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Excellent food and service. I had mentioned through OpenTable that we would be celebrating my husband's birthday and requested to sit inside the vault. When we arrived they were aware of my request and gave us excellent seating and the waiter told me that he was also aware of the birthday celebration. We had a fantastic night and fantastic meal.

Melden
Nuttig
t
5 recensies
Gegeten op 6 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Extremely satisfied with our experience! The steaks were cooked perfectly. The service was on point. We look forward to visiting again!

Melden
Nuttig
TS
1 recensie
Gegeten op 5 januari 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 5sfeer 4

Had a great time at Butcher and Banker. Steak was terrific! Service was extremely attentive. Salads were delicious but will really feed 2 people. Meal was a little pricey, but price goes with quality.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 3 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

The porterhouse steak for two was plenty for us both including our 11 year old son. The wine pairing was excellent and the cheese cake was succulent. The entire diner was an experience in itself.

Melden
Nuttig
JK
1 recensie
Gegeten op 3 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great food and excellent service! The ambiance was quiet and classy but it doesn't make you afraid to make some noise and have a good time! I would definitely come again! The general manager, George, was friendly and super accommodating!! He helped make the experience even more enjoyable.

Melden
Nuttig
JF
Washington, D.C
4 recensies
Gegeten op 2 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

Excellent steak dinner. Good service. Plan to return next time in nyc

Melden
Nuttig
B
1 recensie
Gegeten op 2 januari 2019
Algeheel 3eten 2bediening 3sfeer 5

My boyfriend and I went here before a game at MSG. We weren't seated inside the vault but thats okay, the ambiance was still really cool. The food however was not. My boyfriend ordered a braised short rib which was terribly dry and was incredibly difficult to get off the bone. For the price of the meal, we were highly disappointed.

Melden
Nuttig
MB
1 recensie
Gegeten op 1 januari 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Went there for NYE, and the food was amazing. The service was at that same level as well, very happy with our choice!

Melden
Nuttig
OT
Columbus
2 recensies
Gegeten op 31 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

I took my girlfriend here for New Years and it was a wonderful dining experience.

Melden
Nuttig
BG
1 recensie
Gegeten op 31 december 2018
Algeheel 1eten 1bediening 1sfeer 1

Disgusting atmosphere filled with tourists and a wait staff that is innatentive and forgot numerous parts of our order in addition to overcooking our steak.

Hostess outside let the bar area become filled with coats on the floor and a general sloppy atmosphere. Would not recommend this place to anyone who is not staying at the Hotel, and even if staying there...go some place else.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
Jacksonville /
1 recensie
Gegeten op 31 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

The food was excellent! The steaks were a great cut and cooked perfectly. All of the sides were delicious as was the shrimp cocktail. We sat in the vault which was a cool experience next time we’ll sit in the dining room to try that out. We would recommend trying it out.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 30 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

GREAT SERVICE AMAZING STEAK MY NEW FAVORITE RESTAURANT

Melden
Nuttig
OT
2 recensies
Gegeten op 30 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great dinner in a really cool atmosphere. Steaks were very good. Our waiter was friendly and even gave us a dessert sampler on the house. When we’re back in NYC, we’ll be sure to visit again!

Melden
Nuttig
D
12 recensies
Gegeten op 29 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Came here with mr family after seeing the Donna Summer play on broadway. Beautiful ambiance. Great atmosphere. Perfect service. No complaints. I’ve already made a reservation to go back on my birthday in two weeks! Can’t wait

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 29 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great food and service

Melden
Nuttig
LM
Philadelphia /
5 recensies
Gegeten op 28 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

simply amazing in every way, from service to food

Melden
Nuttig
JR
1 recensie
Gegeten op 27 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Amazing steak, in fact best ever had and I have been to some good places prior! Recommend the 'cowboy ribeye', my wife had the fillet, both of which were superb and I can almost still taste the yummy-ness of it!! The setting in the bank vault is very cool and adds to the experience.

Melden
Nuttig
CJ
1 recensie
Gegeten op 26 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Beautiful unique dining environment! Professional staff, lovely food in taste and presentation.

Melden
Nuttig
MG
1 recensie
Gegeten op 25 december 2018
Algeheel 1eten 3bediening 1sfeer 1

Staff that met us at the entrance where very unfriendly, no smile, it was Christmas day after all, nothing, just looked us up and down, our Waiter made the effort to make conversation. Over all wouldn't recommend it

Melden
Nuttig
AD
13 recensies
Gegeten op 25 december 2018
Algeheel 1eten 2bediening 2sfeer 5

The M’aitre D was extremely rude when my parents arrived to check in for their wedding anniversary dinner. When I called to confirm the reservation I asked the receptionist to note this was a special occasion. My parents had to refire the steaks twice due to taking the order wrong. Despite the server mentioning management would stop by the table, the manager never stopped by and did not address the poor service issue.

Melden
Nuttig
m
9 recensies
Gegeten op 24 december 2018
Algeheel 3eten 2bediening 4sfeer 4

You need to walk thru an ultra busy hotel lobby with barely any signage to find this place. Than when you do, you are greeted by someone texting who is not thrilled to be interrupted and will not ask if you need to check your coat. Your waiter will oddly. Part of this restaurants appeal/ charm is that it's located in the old vault of a bank. So it's very disappointing and strange to not be seated in the actual vault space when barely anyone is in there. While the food ranged from ok to good to inedible there is no reason to ever go here. Every place can have an off night but when someone tells you a piece of fish is inedible it should not remain on the bill. Period full stop. If you get sucked in and really want to check out the space, go have a drink at the bar. It's very cool. Maybe some sliders and a duck fat potato cake.. they were great.... but for dinner move on. This is NYC.. plenty of other places more worthy and appreciative of your time/money.

Melden
Nuttig
BS
1 recensie
Gegeten op 23 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

I bought my boyfriend here for his birthday and he LOVED it.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
Philadelphia /
1 recensie
Gegeten op 22 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

After play meal before taking train home. Food was absolutely amazing. The service was excellent. It was definitely worth it.

Melden
Nuttig
N
Virginia
7 recensies
Gegeten op 22 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Food is so savory. Amazing ambiance. Would definitely go back.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
Atlanta / Georg
2 recensies
Gegeten op 21 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Awesome steak! Cheesecake was the best!

Melden
Nuttig
A
Los Angeles
4 recensies
Gegeten op 21 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Juan Miguel was Ana amazing server. The short rib was the best I’ve ever had! The decor was beautiful and the ambiance was great. I’ll definitely return!

Melden
Nuttig
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 21 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

I had a great time , the food was excellent.. highly recommended

Melden
Nuttig
J
15 recensies
Gegeten op 20 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

Good food, great service and a very unique dining room!

Melden
Nuttig
d
36 recensies
Gegeten op 20 december 2018
Algeheel 3eten 2bediening 3sfeer 2

Always looking for an interesting spot in NYC for dinner or drinks and came across this place in an article. Liked the idea it was in the Old New Yorker with a deco vibe and quasi speakeasy feel. However once you were there the place just felt a bit tattered. While our waitress was nice there was just a cold, low energy feel to the place. Too many other better options in the city to go back here again.

Melden
Nuttig
BF
Londen
18 recensies
Gegeten op 20 december 2018
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

We enjoyed a quiet dinner in the vault and an rate the steak as outstanding quality as well as the delicious crab cakes. The wait staff were friendly and fun and made the experience special.

Melden
Nuttig
M
Orlando / Oost-
41 recensies
Gegeten op 20 december 2018
Algeheel 3eten 2bediening 2sfeer 5

The atmosphere was terrific, dining in an old bank vault. The food was nothing terrific...nothing special. The service was really lacking. Our steaks were both done incorrectly. The veggies we ordered were barely warm. I would not go back, but it was something unusual because of the atmosphere.

Melden
Nuttig
PJ
1 recensie
Gegeten op 19 december 2018
Algeheel 3eten 4bediening 1sfeer 3

The waiter was so arrogant it was (almost) funny. And, let's face it--anyone can cook a steak.

Melden
Nuttig
OT
3 recensies
Gegeten op 19 december 2018
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great meal. Great service. Juan was our server and he was great! Great steakhouse ambiance in the vault.

Melden
Nuttig
1
2
3
8