Carmelo's Coat of Arms

4.8
388 recensies
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
van 31 $ tot 50 $
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.
Italiaans
Populairste tags:
  • Speciale gelegenheid
  • Creatieve keuken
  • Lokale ingrediënten
Wat 388 mensen zeggen
Algehele beoordelingen en recensies
Alleen gasten die bij dit restaurant hebben gegeten, kunnen recensies schrijven
4.8op basis van recente beoordelingen
4.9
eten
4.8
bediening
4.6
sfeer
4.5
prijs-kwaliteit
Geluid · Stil
98% van de mensen zouden dit aan hun vrienden aanbevelen
5
4
3
2
1
Sorteer op
Filters
J
1 recensie
3 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

The food was exquisite, the cocktails were just right, and our server was excellent - very intuitive about pacing our meal as we wanted to linger and enjoy each course. A perfect evening!

Melden
OT
Philadelphia /
25 recensies
4 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Top notch venue in Center Street in Lewiston! Waitress was skilled and warm. Meal was delicious! Good wine selection.

Melden
DD
12 recensies
4 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great food and wonderful staff

Melden
RJ
22 recensies
6 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Carmelo's is a consistently excellent restaurant. Food is top notch and service always excellent. We eat here several times per month and are never disappointed.

Melden
OT
1 recensie
6 dagen geleden gegeten
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Phenomenal as always. Perfect serving size. Enough to enjoy but not enough to regret because it was so good.

Melden
HE
1 recensie
Gegeten op 13 augustus 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 4sfeer 4

I tried to get a seat by the window. they said they couldn't do that for us..... but no one sat there until we were leaving. if they would have said "we can accommodate you but we have another reservation at 8:15"... we would have made sure we were done eating by then.

Also - my husband ordered another glass of wine and the waitress almost took the other glass that he wasn't completely done with out of his hand. he set it down for a second. she picked it up and poured the left over few sips into the new glass of wine... i just dont feel that should happen especially at a nice place like this.

Overall i loved it... and will come back again . Next time i will reserve a table by the window way in advance!

Melden
CM
4 recensies
Gegeten op 10 augustus 2019
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

Fantastic service and great food. Would love to go back-it was worth the ride. My rigatoni with roasted eggplant and a few sardines was fantastic and was my husband's bolognese. Our budino for dessert was excellent!

Melden
JB
1 recensie
Gegeten op 6 augustus 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Amazing service - Excellent food - Phenomenal Atmosphere

Melden
DD
13 recensies
Gegeten op 6 augustus 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Best Resturant around

Melden
RM
Washington, D.C
9 recensies
Gegeten op 3 augustus 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Food and service was great. Sound level in loud in side dining room.

Melden
DF
4 recensies
Gegeten op 2 augustus 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 3

I consider myself, a fairly good "home cook". As a result, I walk out of many restaurants very disappointed with an average meal and the price paid for such. This never happens at Carmelo's. Our recent meal was delicious. The halibut with lentils was fabulous. The three other diners at my table chose the bucatini, which they raved about. We finished with a wonderful ricotta cheesecake. The only thing that would make Carmelo's better would be some increased space between tables...noise and privacy of conversation can be a problem some evenings. Nevertheless, it definitely remains our favorite restaurant.

Melden
E
35 recensies
Gegeten op 2 augustus 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

Having just returned from a couple of weeks in Italy, we chose Carmelo's as a way to help us adjust to being back in the states......And it did the trick. We had great wine, excellent food, a wonderful waitress (April), and a grand time with friends (who had just returned from a Croatian holiday). Not just one of the best restaurants in Niagara County, but I think in all of Western New York.

Melden
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 31 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

The staff at Carmelo’s is awesome! We had popped in on a busy night to try to get a table, and the hostess said it would be 30-45 minutes. With a concert starting in just over an hour and a half, we decided to try elsewhere. I checked on Open Table and saw that a reservation for Carmelo’s had appeared for 15 minutes later, and I snagged it. When we walked back into the restaurant, the hostess greeted us with a huge smile and waved us through the mass of people trying to get a table. She said someone had cancelled their reservation a minute after we walked out, and that she was so glad when she saw us grab it through Open Table. Timing could not have been better, and the food was fantastic, so we totally lucked out!!

Melden
JA
3 recensies
Gegeten op 27 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Food was superb. I had the halibut and I licked my plate clean. We always have a great experience here. There was a very loud 4some which made it loud this evening. It was a little overwhelming some guy bragging about his life. The restaurant can’t do anything about obnoxious patrons.

Melden
TB
1 recensie
Gegeten op 27 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Simple elegance, delectable dishes. This place never disappoints!

Melden
C
1 recensie
Gegeten op 24 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Delicious food skillfully prepared and expertly served. A restaurant you can return to frequently since the menu changes per local food availability. Always a pleasure to dine here!

Melden
LS
1 recensie
Gegeten op 20 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

I’ve wanted to have dinner at Carmelo’s for quite some time, but was a little worried that it might not live up to my expectations. My concern was needless, however. Both of our entries (hanger steak and halibut) were outstanding, as was our entire evening. There is not, in my opinion, a finer dining experience in Western New York.

Melden
G
1 recensie
Gegeten op 20 juli 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 5sfeer 5

Been here several times. We like it. Did notice that portions were on the small side, making it relatively expensive. No one had leftovers. Appetizers were too small to share. Fish entrees were embarrassingly small. Given how its menu is fresh and local, choices are limited and never the same from one night to the next. They ran out of one pasta, but did accommodate a substitute. Nice service and ambience.

Melden
MP
Virginia
4 recensies
Gegeten op 20 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Excellent homemade pasta. Superb dining experience.

Melden
JS
1 recensie
Gegeten op 19 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

We haven't been to Carmelo's in a while but were pleased with the food and the service. Our friends were very pleased also.

Melden
B
Washington, D.C
3 recensies
Gegeten op 19 juli 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 4

Classic Italian Restaurant in a fine little town. Wait staff excellent, attentive without being obtrusive, helpful with choices.

Melden
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 12 juli 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

We absolutely loved every part of the evening, the calamari salad was incredible and the shrimp pasta did was wonderful our server Diane was a pleasure, we cannot wait to go back!

Melden
JG
1 recensie
Gegeten op 6 juli 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 4sfeer 5

Delicious food, great drinks, and much improved environment since our last visit.

Melden
AB
8 recensies
Gegeten op 6 juli 2019
Algeheel 4eten 5bediening 2sfeer 3

The food was well presented and very tasty. We split a few orders and they put the items on separate plates, which was appreciated. The food came in a reasonable amount of time. We had the lamb and calamari appatizers, both very well prepared. The main dishes were also excellent as were the deserts. The choices of wine was good. The wait-staff, while friendly, was not that attentive and we did have to request a few items 2-3 times. But, we will go back because the food was excellent

Melden
MG
1 recensie
Gegeten op 29 juni 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Consistently excellent food and attentive service. Can’t go wrong when you book a reservation at Carmelo’s

Melden
MS
1 recensie
Gegeten op 15 juni 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

One of my favorite places. Excellent food, excellent service, great staff, definitely will be back

Melden
a
Londen
8 recensies
Gegeten op 15 juni 2019
Algeheel 4eten 4bediening 3sfeer 3

A very good dining experience. We enjoyed the food, and our waitress was friendly and competent. However, our drinks were a big disappointment. Three of four of us were unsatisfied with the cocktails we ordered. The Cosmos had too much cranberry and the Moscow Mule tasted nothing like a Moscow Mule should.

Melden
DD
13 recensies
Gegeten op 23 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

New menu items !!! CR chicken made me think I was eating at a Jonathan Waxman Resturant. Lamb ribs are unique, creative and awesome. Bolognese is the dish that will keep you coming back- the best pasta

Melden
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 18 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 4bediening 5sfeer 4

The waitress was great!!! Diane

Melden
p
22 recensies
Gegeten op 16 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Best duck I’ve ever had. Great place!!

Melden
ES
1 recensie
Gegeten op 11 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Chef/ owner operated restaurant. Carefully crafted food using fresh, quality ingredients. Nice wine and beer list.

Melden
CB
Tampa / West-Ce
5 recensies
Gegeten op 11 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

This was our second visit. Our waitress Katie was great and very knowledgeable. The food was amazing. I love Italian but could not resist the duck breast and it seriously was one of the best I ever had. My companion had pasta bolognese homemade and perfectly done.

Melden
G
2 recensies
Gegeten op 11 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 3sfeer 5

Will be back again. Steak was top notch! Squid ink pasta was also incredible. Waitress was very friendly and knowledgeable.

Melden
OT
2 recensies
Gegeten op 3 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 4sfeer 5

Carmelo's never disappoints! The duck was amazing, skin was so crispy. And my wife won't stop talking about how delicious her crispy potatoes were! We will definitely be back soon!

Melden
TB
Phoenix / Arizo
1 recensie
Gegeten op 2 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great cuisine prepared with special love. A fine chef. I was with two dear friends and we usually hold hands and offer a prayer before we eat. The really sweet and very competent waitress we had came and added her hands to our circle and prayed with us. Also great hammered copper bar. Do not miss going here

Melden
OT
1 recensie
Gegeten op 2 mei 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great fresh unique

Melden
C
1 recensie
Gegeten op 16 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

The food was outstanding!!!
If we weren’t passing thru town Carmelo’s would be our GO TO restaurant. Definite destination next time we’re in town.

Melden
JS
Tampa / West-Ce
1 recensie
Gegeten op 16 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Great food, service and atmosphere. What more would one want?

Melden
DD
13 recensies
Gegeten op 13 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 5

Best bolognese in the world!

Melden
M
5 recensies
Gegeten op 12 april 2019
Algeheel 5eten 5bediening 5sfeer 4

Tasty, fresh ingredients. Perfectly prepared. Menu changes often.

Melden
1
2
3
10