Fatfish On The Water

4,5 (234)

van $31 tot $50

Zeevruchten

28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Over dit restaurant

Lekker buiten eten
Geweldig voor uitzicht
Juweeltje in de wijk

Overlooking Long Island’s gorgeous Great South Bay, Fatfish is a lively Mediterranean-inspired seafood destination. Offering panoramic bay views from the outdoor patio seating, live music at the outside bar & a cozy wine bar facing the canal. The menu celebrates the rich flavors of the ocean along with favorites from the land including steaks and pork chops, paired with an innovative tapas selection. Indulge in the signature seafood dishes from tender lobster, buttery scallops, or flavorful whole fish. Wine lovers can peruse our worldly selection of reserves, along with 25 local and international varieties available by the glass.

Niet beschikbaar op OpenTable

Dit restaurant maakt helaas geen deel uit van het reserveringsnetwerk van OpenTable. Neem voor meer info over beschikbaarheid rechtstreeks contact met ze op.

Is dit uw restaurant?

Claim deze vermelding

Er valt nog meer te ontdekken

Ontdek nog veel meer restaurants zoals deze met onze app.

Scan de QR-code om nog veel meer restaurants zoals deze te ontdekken met onze app.

Open app

Aanvullende informatie

Stijl
Casual chique
Prijs
van $31 tot $50
Keuken
Zeevruchten
Openingstijden
di–do 11:30 uur–21:00 uur vr, za 11:30 uur–21:30 uur zo 11:30 uur–18:00 uur Bar di–za 15:30 uur–16:30 uur
Telefoonnummer
(631) 666-2899
Website
http://fatfish.info/
Kledingvoorschrift
Zakelijk casual
Chef-kok
Brian Valdini

Locatie
28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Wijk
Bay Shore
Parkeerinformatie
Openbaar parkeerterrein
Extra
Glutenvrije opties, Patio/Buiten eten, Rolstoeltoegang, Uitgebreide bar, Uitzicht, Veganist

Minted Lamb Chops (2)US$ 17,00
Char-grilled parsley garlic lemon sauce
Chorizo & PeppersUS$ 12,00
Tempranillo scallion red wine sauce
Tenderloin Skewers (2)US$ 17,00
Spanish blue cheese butter sauce
Empanadas (3)US$ 17,00
Traditional potato & meat filled pastry
Charcuterie PlateUS$ 25,00
Palacios chorizo~ Parma ham~ Pepperoni soppresata~ Speck~ artichokes~ roasted peppers~ parmigiano reggiano~ flatbreads
Lemon & Thyme Roasted Chicken WingsUS$ 16,00
horseradish dijon mustard sauce
CevicheUS$ 19,00
local fluke citrus marinate tomatoes red onion avocado
Tuna TostadoUS$ 19,00
fresh raw tuna lime juice shallots avocado crunchy corn tortilla siracha mayonnaise and wasabi mayonnaise
Tapas ScallopsUS$ 19,00
Sautéed with shallot paprika lemon olive oil diced tomato
Oysters Rockefeller (2)US$ 14,00
baked with spinach creamy Pernod sauce
Lemon & Garlic Shrimp (5)US$ 17,00
sautéed with garlic lemon olive oil smoked paprika
Saffron MusselsUS$ 18,00
creamy aromatic sauce fennel chives tomato concasse
Steamed Little Neck ClamsUS$ 16,00
chorizo white wine parsley garlic
Broiled Oysters (4) US$ 18,00
garlic butter parsley lemon parmesan cheese
Patatas BravasUS$ 10,00
crispy potatoes spicy paprika seasoning garlic mayonnaise
Wild Mushroom Rice BallsUS$ 12,00
fresh mozzarella panko bread crumbs parsley chive oil
Artichoke HeartsUS$ 15,00
crispy fried artichokes whipped herbed ricotta cheese
Vegetable FlatbreadUS$ 15,00
artichokes tomatoes red onion goat cheese manchego cheese
Mediterranean PlateUS$ 15,00
hummus olive tapenade marinated feta baked pita bread
Artisan Cheeses (4) US$ 26,00
Valdeon blue cheese ~ manchego ~ Reserve cornelia ~ Humboldt fog and pear chutney ~ fig spread ~ flat bread ~ fig almond bread ~ baguette
Rosemary ManchegoUS$ 10,00
marinated in olive oil membrillo quince flat bread

Raw Bar

East Coast OystersUS$ 3,50
cocktail sauce mignonette horseradish
West Coast OystersUS$ 4,50
cocktail sauce mignonette horseradish
Oyster Hot ShotUS$ 15,00
Salsa (tequila salsa lime juice) or Cocktail (vodka cocktail sauce pepper lemon)
6 Little Neck ClamsUS$ 13,00
north shore
2 Colossal Shrimp CocktailUS$ 16,00

Soup & Salads

Lobster Bisque US$ 17,00
brandy fresh lobster
Grilled Shrimp SaladUS$ 25,00
red onion tomato orange toasted almonds chick peas arugula Boston Bibb lettuce lemon chive olive oil
Portabello & Grilled Asparagus SaladUS$ 16,00
grilled marinated mushrooms and asparagus mixed arugula greens roasted peppers grape tomatoes manchego cheese roasted walnuts red wine chive vinaigrette
Roasted Pear & Golden Beet SaladUS$ 16,00
arugula Spanish Blue Valdeon pine nuts Italian white balsamic vinaigrette
North Fork SaladUS$ 16,00
organic greens Manchego Cheese strawberries Spanish Marcona almonds minted balsamic vinaigrette
Chicken & Pancetta Salad (Main Course) US$ 30,00
organic chicken breast avocado gorgonzola pancetta tomatoes baby romaine arugula lettuce with chive vinaigrette
Add to Any Salad:
Tuna (15) Salmon (14) Grilled Shrimp (4.50/ea) Organic Chicken (14) Skirt Steak (16) Grilled Scallops (4/20PC)

Starters

Beef CarpaccioUS$ 22,00
grana padano crostini truffle olive oil
Lobster RisottoUS$ 35,00
basil chives parmesan cheese orange segments
Baked Clams (8)US$ 16,00
oregano garlic parsley butter sauce
Jumbo Lump Crab CakesUS$ 28,00
baked spicy celery remoulade
Char-Grilled OctopusUS$ 22,00
grilled mixed bean salsa arugula lemon spanish paprika olive oil
Mediterranean Seafood SaladUS$ 21,00
shrimp calamari octopus mussels mixed peppers lemon-olive oil basil dressing
MusselsUS$ 20,00
spicy-herb tomato or garlic white wine butter sauce
Tempura CalamariUS$ 19,00
tender strips chili mayonnaise spicy tomato basil sauce
Buffalo Mozzarella & TomatoUS$ 18,00
imported mozzarella beefsteak tomato balsamic reduction
Shrimp in Trench Coats (5)US$ 17,00
beer battered lemon-herb mayonnaise
Mushroom GnocchiUS$ 15,00
sautéed cremini mushrooms garlic white wine basil roasted cherry tomatoes parmesan cheese cream sauce

Main Courses

Ribeye Steak (16 oz) US$ 64,00
grilled plum tomatoes asparagus mushroom hand-cut fries burgundy wine sauce
Cedar River Farms Filet Mignon (10 oz)US$ 68,00
pancetta potato au gratin French beans baby carrots caramelized red onion Cabernet sauce
Pork Chop (10 oz)US$ 36,00
asparagus hand-cut fries spiced cherry pepper burgundy wine sauce
Pan-seared Breast of ChickenUS$ 32,00
rosemary tomato risotto asparagus touch of goat cheese roasted chicken au jus
Open RavioliUS$ 22,00
goat cheese mozzarella cherry tomato mixed olives fresh herb tomato sauce
Cauliflower Pizza (Gluten Free/Vegan)US$ 21,00
roasted eggplant portobello mushrooms arugula caramelized red onion roasted pepper
Add a Lobster Tail to Any MealUS$ 35,00

Sea to Table

FlukeUS$ 42,00
local Montauk filet roasted sauvignon butter oysters baby spinach tomato thyme roasted potato
HalibutUS$ 40,00
paan seared mushroom grated pesto shrimp veloute asparagus toasted pistachio
SwordfishUS$ 40,00
char-grilled smoked paprika lemon olive oil tomato confit grilled eggplant sautéed French beans & baby carrots hand cut parmesan fries
TunaUS$ 42,00
citrus pepper lemon basmati rice crab tempura asparagus baby carrot wasabi sauce soy sauce (cooked rare or cooked through)
SalmonUS$ 36,00
farm raised roasted lemon vine roasted fennel tomato vegetable spinach sauce roasted potato
Seared Scallop MeunièreUS$ 45,00
lightly seasoned scallops lemon butter fresh tomato parsley saffron orzo sautéed spinach
Twin Lobster Tails US$ 72,00
roasted fingerling potatoes French beans baby carrots lemon garlic butter sauce
Shrimp & Scallop FettuccineUS$ 42,00
sautéed cremini mushrooms fresh baby arugula garlic roasted peppers basil cream sauce
Fish & ChipsUS$ 30,00
hand-cut local fish beer battered seasonal vegetables thick cut fries

For the Table

Patatas BravasUS$ 12,00
AsparagusUS$ 12,00
Sautéed Wild Mushrooms with Garlic Parsley Olive OilUS$ 12,00
Spinach in Garlic ButterUS$ 12,00
Hand-Cut FriesUS$ 12,00
with garlic aioli and spicy mayonnaise
Potato Au GratinUS$ 12,00

Reviews

OpenTable-reviews van geverifieerde gasten

Reviews van mensen die bij Fatfish On The Water hebben gegeten.

4.5

(234)

4,5Eten
4,5Bediening
4,6Sfeer
4,1Prijs-kwaliteitverhouding

Geluid • Redelijk rustig

234 Reviews

M
Maura
New York City7 recensies
3.0
Gegeten op 23 oktober 2025
1. Algeheel 3
2. Eten 3
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
Service and ambience were wonderful. The lobster but was extremely expensive and not very good. The lobster was chopped into small pieces and was actually tasteless. Also there was very little bacon.
Is dit nuttig?
L
Laura Gold
Orlando / Centraal-Florida Oost20 recensies
5.0
Gegeten op 1 oktober 2025
1. Algeheel 5
2. Eten 5
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
We celebrated our anniversary having an early dinner on the patio. The scenery is so beautiful, romantic and serene there. We both had the salmon which was delicious, and our server was very attentive. We both love Fat Fish, and I even had one of my husband’s birthday celebrations there.
Is dit nuttig?
N
Natalia
New York City2 recensies
4.0
Gegeten op 26 september 2025
1. Algeheel 4
2. Eten 5
3. Bediening 3
4. Sfeer 5
the food and ambience was amazing. The views were incredible slightly after appetizers. We felt quite rushed by the waitress, which I did not appreciate since it was a birthday dinner with me and my girlfriends but everything else was excellent.
Is dit nuttig?
W
William
New York City18 recensies
5.0
Gegeten op 20 september 2025
1. Algeheel 5
2. Eten 5
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
Great views of the great south bay! Great food, service and price! Nice way to relax and enjoy with friend's.
Is dit nuttig?
G
Gail Gold
New York City58 recensies
5.0
Gegeten op 19 september 2025
1. Algeheel 5
2. Eten 3
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
Beautiful evening with a beautiful view. Friendly & attentive service. Food was mostly good but I had the SEARED SCALLOP MEUNIÉRE. The scallops were good but it had sauteed spinach atop parsley orzo. I don't know why there was a vinegarette tasting dressing on the spinach. It detracted from a pricey dish & seemed unnecessary. I would have preferred just a simple sauteed spinach. Otherwise it was a great experience.
Is dit nuttig?
r
russell Gold
Staat New York55 recensies
5.0
Gegeten op 19 september 2025
1. Algeheel 5
2. Eten 5
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
We have been here several times. Always very good. When people want water view this place is literally on the water. Nice Tapas menu as well.
Is dit nuttig?
J
John Gold
New York City8 recensies
5.0
Gegeten op 19 september 2025
1. Algeheel 5
2. Eten 5
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
I can’t thank everyone for an amazing night everything was just perfect weather food service thank you
Is dit nuttig?
S
Susanne Gold
New York City55 recensies
5.0
Gegeten op 13 september 2025
1. Algeheel 5
2. Eten 5
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
Food and service were great! It was a little noisy. We sat out in the outdoor space (plastic walls) which was pleasant even though it was raining a little. I would recommend!!
Is dit nuttig?
M
Mike Gold
New York City39 recensies
5.0
Gegeten op 13 september 2025
1. Algeheel 5
2. Eten 5
3. Bediening 5
4. Sfeer 5
Fat fish has always been a favorite there view is gorgeous to the great South Bay! There drinks are amazing! The food and specials are outstanding!!
Is dit nuttig?
M
Mario J Gold
New York City95 recensies
3.0
Gegeten op 12 september 2025
1. Algeheel 3
2. Eten 3
3. Bediening 2
4. Sfeer 4
Food and service were night and day different from our visit in May.
Is dit nuttig?

Aanvullende informatie

Stijl
Casual chique
Prijs
van $31 tot $50
Keuken
Zeevruchten
Openingstijden
di–do 11:30 uur–21:00 uur vr, za 11:30 uur–21:30 uur zo 11:30 uur–18:00 uur Bar di–za 15:30 uur–16:30 uur
Telefoonnummer
(631) 666-2899
Website
http://fatfish.info/
Kledingvoorschrift
Zakelijk casual
Chef-kok
Brian Valdini

Locatie
28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Wijk
Bay Shore
Parkeerinformatie
Openbaar parkeerterrein
Extra
Glutenvrije opties, Patio/Buiten eten, Rolstoeltoegang, Uitgebreide bar, Uitzicht, Veganist

Niet beschikbaar op OpenTable

Dit restaurant maakt helaas geen deel uit van het reserveringsnetwerk van OpenTable. Neem voor meer info over beschikbaarheid rechtstreeks contact met ze op.

Is dit uw restaurant?

Claim deze vermelding

Fatfish On The Water

Over dit restaurant

Niet beschikbaar op OpenTable

Er valt nog meer te ontdekken

Aanvullende informatie

Tapas

Minted Lamb Chops (2)US$ 17,00

Chorizo & PeppersUS$ 12,00

Tenderloin Skewers (2)US$ 17,00

Empanadas (3)US$ 17,00

Charcuterie PlateUS$ 25,00

Lemon & Thyme Roasted Chicken WingsUS$ 16,00

CevicheUS$ 19,00

Tuna TostadoUS$ 19,00

Tapas ScallopsUS$ 19,00

Oysters Rockefeller (2)US$ 14,00

Lemon & Garlic Shrimp (5)US$ 17,00

Saffron MusselsUS$ 18,00

Steamed Little Neck ClamsUS$ 16,00

Broiled Oysters (4) US$ 18,00

Patatas BravasUS$ 10,00

Wild Mushroom Rice BallsUS$ 12,00

Artichoke HeartsUS$ 15,00

Vegetable FlatbreadUS$ 15,00

Mediterranean PlateUS$ 15,00

Artisan Cheeses (4) US$ 26,00

Rosemary ManchegoUS$ 10,00

Raw Bar

East Coast OystersUS$ 3,50

West Coast OystersUS$ 4,50

Oyster Hot ShotUS$ 15,00

6 Little Neck ClamsUS$ 13,00

2 Colossal Shrimp CocktailUS$ 16,00

Soup & Salads

Lobster Bisque US$ 17,00

Grilled Shrimp SaladUS$ 25,00

Portabello & Grilled Asparagus SaladUS$ 16,00

Roasted Pear & Golden Beet SaladUS$ 16,00

North Fork SaladUS$ 16,00

Chicken & Pancetta Salad (Main Course) US$ 30,00

Add to Any Salad:

Starters

Beef CarpaccioUS$ 22,00

Lobster RisottoUS$ 35,00

Baked Clams (8)US$ 16,00

Jumbo Lump Crab CakesUS$ 28,00

Char-Grilled OctopusUS$ 22,00

Mediterranean Seafood SaladUS$ 21,00

MusselsUS$ 20,00

Tempura CalamariUS$ 19,00

Buffalo Mozzarella & TomatoUS$ 18,00

Shrimp in Trench Coats (5)US$ 17,00

Mushroom GnocchiUS$ 15,00

Main Courses

Ribeye Steak (16 oz) US$ 64,00

Cedar River Farms Filet Mignon (10 oz)US$ 68,00

Pork Chop (10 oz)US$ 36,00

Pan-seared Breast of ChickenUS$ 32,00

Open RavioliUS$ 22,00

Cauliflower Pizza (Gluten Free/Vegan)US$ 21,00

Add a Lobster Tail to Any MealUS$ 35,00

Sea to Table

FlukeUS$ 42,00

HalibutUS$ 40,00

SwordfishUS$ 40,00

TunaUS$ 42,00

SalmonUS$ 36,00

Seared Scallop MeunièreUS$ 45,00

Twin Lobster Tails US$ 72,00

Shrimp & Scallop FettuccineUS$ 42,00

Fish & ChipsUS$ 30,00

For the Table

Patatas BravasUS$ 12,00

AsparagusUS$ 12,00

Sautéed Wild Mushrooms with Garlic Parsley Olive OilUS$ 12,00

Spinach in Garlic ButterUS$ 12,00

Hand-Cut FriesUS$ 12,00

Potato Au GratinUS$ 12,00

Aanvullende informatie

Niet beschikbaar op OpenTable