Lobster Roll - Amagansett

Appetizers

• Mixed Green SaladUS$ 6,50

  Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing.

• Clams on the Half Shell*

  Six Fresh cold water raw clams from certified packers.

  • Market Price

• Shrimp CocktailUS$ 16,95

  Six large shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce.

• The Finest Steamers & Broth

  (Full Quart). The South Fork classic "soft shell" clam.

  • Market Price

• Mussels MarinaraUS$ 13,95

  A full quart! Plump mussels, served with Paul's zesty marinara sauce.

• Plump MusselsUS$ 13,95

  A full quart! Steamed in their own bag and served with herbed garlic butter

• Seafood NachosUS$ 17,95

  A big plate of tortilla chips dressed with seafood chili, melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, scallions and tangy salsa.

• Clams Casino

  Clams on the half shell broiled in a herbed-garlic butter sauce and topped with bacon.

  • Market Price

• Crab Cake AppetizerUS$ 11,50

  Grilled and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.

• Puffers

  Choice of 1/2 Order OR Full Order. Boneless, mild fish, fried in our special tempura batter and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.

  • Market Price

• Fried Clam Strips

  Crispy strips of tender deep sea clams fried to crunchy perfection. Served with tartar sauce.

  • Small plateUS$ 14,95
  • Large plateUS$ 7,50

• Fish-n'-Chips (minus the fries)

  Pure white coldwater cod dipped in tempura batter and fried to crunchy perfection! Served with tartar sauce.

  • Large plateUS$ 14,95
  • Small plateUS$ 7,50

• Fried CalamariUS$ 16,50

  Lightly seasoned and served with Paul's own homemade zesty marinara sauce.

• Chicken FingersUS$ 9,95

  Chicken breast fried crispy & golden. Served with BBQ sauce.

• Battered Onion RingsUS$ 9,50

  Sweet large onions fried golden brown.

• Cheese NachosUS$ 11,95

  Corn tortilla chips topped with melted cheddar, sour cream, and scallions. Served with salsa.

• Buffalo Chicken WingsUS$ 15,95

  Crispy, white meat chicken wings coated in hot sauce and served with blue cheese dressing.

Chowder & Bisque

• Homemade Creamy New England Chowder

  Our trademark creamy soup made with lots of clams.

  • CrockUS$ 7,50
  • Quart (to go)US$ 19,50

• Homemade Hearty Manhattan Seafood Chowder

  Our own tomato-based soup, loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops & cod.

  • CrockUS$ 7,50
  • Quart (to go)US$ 19,50

• Homemade Lobster Seafood Bisque

  A hearty blend of lobster, shrimp and scallops with a touch of sherry...rich and creamy.

  • CrockUS$ 8,75
  • Quart (to go)US$ 24,50

Lobster Salad

All served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

• The Hot Lobster Roll

  Tasty chunks of hot lobster meat served in drawn butter, with toasted hot dog buns on the side and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

  • Market Price
  • With Fries AddUS$ 2,75

• The "Classic" Lobster Roll

  • Market Price
  • With Fries AddUS$ 2,75

• Lobster Slider

  A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

  • Market Price
  • With Fries AddUS$ 2,75

• Lobster Bowl

  One scoop on a small tossed salad.

  • Market Price
  • With Fries AddUS$ 2,75

• Lobster Platter

  Two scoops on a large salad with fries.

  • Market Price
  • With Fries AddUS$ 2,75

Shrimp Salad

All served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

• The "Classic" Shrimp RollUS$ 16,95

  • With Fries AddUS$ 2,75

• Shrimp SliderUS$ 9,50

  A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

• Shrimp BowlUS$ 20,95

  One scoop on a small tossed salad.

• Shrimp PlatterUS$ 24,95

  Two scoops on a large salad with fries.

White Albacore Tuna

All served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

• The "Classic" Tuna RollUS$ 9,95

  • With Fries AddUS$ 2,75

• Tuna SliderUS$ 5,95

  A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

• Tuna BowlUS$ 12,95

  One scoop on a small tossed salad.

• Tuna PlatterUS$ 17,95

  Two scoops on a large salad with fries.

"pub" Sandwich Specialties

All items served on a roll with crispy crinkle-cut fries and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

• Char-broiled Swordfish Steak

  Lightly marinated select swordfish steak, on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

  • Market Price

• Char-broiled Tuna Steak*

  Fresh tuna loin steak on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

  • Market Price

• Broiled Flounder Filet

  Fresh flounder served on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

  • Market Price

• Grandma's Old Fashioned Grilled CrabcakeUS$ 14,95

  "Blue claw" crabcakes served on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

• Fried Flounder Filet

  Breaded, deep fried on a toasted roll with, lettuce & tomato.

  • Market Price

• Fried Clam StripsUS$ 11,95

  Crispy strips of cold-water deep sea clams fried & piled on a toasted roll.

• Fried Soft-Shell CrabUS$ 15,95

  The Chesapeake Bay favorite, fried crispy on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

• Char-broiled Beefburger*US$ 13,50

  Traditional burger made from angus beef, with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

  • Add BaconUS$ 1,75

• Grilled VeggieburgerUS$ 13,95

  A healthful blend of select veggies, delicately seasoned, with lettuce, tomato and a pickle.

• Char-broiled Chicken BreastUS$ 14,95

  Herbed chicken cutlet on a toasted roll, with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

• Golden Grilled CheeseUS$ 7,95

  The old "standby" grilled golden brown and served with a pickle.

  • W/ TomatoUS$ 8,75
  • W/ Bacon and TomatoUS$ 10,50

• All Beef Sabrett's Hot DogUS$ 8,50

  Grilled classic on a buttery toasted roll, served with a pickle.

Specialties

• Fish 'n' ChipsUS$ 18,95

  Atlantic cold water cod dipped in tempura batter and fried to crunchy perfection! Served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, crispy crinkle-cut fries and zesty tartar sauce. Malt vinegar completes the dish!

• Puffers 'n' Chips

  Fried in our special tempura batter and served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, crispy crinkle-cut fries & our homemade remoulade sauce.

  • Market Price

• Paul's Famous Seafood ChiliUS$ 16,95

  A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans, topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream and scallions. served with tortilla chips.

• Grandma's CrabcakesUS$ 23,95

  Grilled premium Blue Claw crabmeat, bread crumbs spices and herbs.

• Steamed Whole Lobsters (1 1/4 lb.)

  Market Price.

• Steamed Whole Lobsters (3 lb.)

  Market Price.

Entree Platters

Broiled Selections

• Jumbo ShrimpUS$ 24,95

  Six tender shrimp broiled "Scampi Style."

• Salmon Filet

  Prepared with a garlic herb sauce. ***Prepared Oreganata Style: Add $1.00

  • Market Price.

• Filet of Flounder

  Fresh boneless filet broiled in butter. ***Prepared Oreganata Style: Add $1.00

  • Market Price

• ScallopsUS$ 26,95

  Sweet, tender sea scallops in a mild garlic-herbed sauce.

Char-broiled Selections

All entrée platters are served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, and your choice of crispy crinkle-cut fries, roasted new potatoes, salad or corn on the cob

• Swordfish Steak

  Center cut steak marinated in herbed wine sauce.

  • Market Price

• Tuna Steak*

  Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in herbed wine sauce.

  • Market Price

• Combo*

  A tasty combination of fresh char-broiled tuna and swordfish steak.

  • Market Price

• Chicken Cutlet PlatterUS$ 19,95

  Pure white meat chicken filets brushed with herbed wine sauce.

• Black Angus Shell Steak*US$ 29,95

  A boneless, hand cut, premium 16 oz. shell steak cooked to your specifications.

Stuffed Selections

• Baked Stuffed FlounderUS$ 25,95

  A house favorite! Crabmeat stuffing with mild melted cheese. Finished with a herbed wine sauce.

• Baked Stuffed Jumbo ShrimpUS$ 25,95

  Crabmeat stuffing, baked to perfection.

Fried Selections

• Fried Clam StripsUS$ 17,95

  Crispy strips of cold water deep sea clams fried golden.

• Fried Sea ScallopsUS$ 26,95

  Lightly dusted and fried to perfection.

• Golden Fried ShrimpUS$ 21,95

  Large shrimp, butterflied, lightly breaded and fried golden.

• Fried Filet of Flounder

  Lightly breaded, fresh boneless filet.

  • Market Price

• Fried Soft Shell CrabsUS$ 26,95

  The original Chesapeake Bay favorite! Two jumbo crabs lightly battered and fried.

• Fried Chicken Cutlet PlatterUS$ 19,95

  Golden fried chicken breast served with honey mustard

Combinations

• Puffer 'n' Fish 'n' Chips

  We combined two of our most popular favorites just for you! Moist cod and mild boneless blowfish, with tartar and remoulade sauce.

  • Market Price

• Captain's Fried CombinationUS$ 26,95

  Breaded shrimp, scallops, and flounder , with tartar and cocktail sauce

• Broiled Seafood CombinationUS$ 26,95

  Large shrimp, scallops and flounder served with scampi butter.

• First Mates Fried CombinationUS$ 26,95

  Breaded shrimp, clam strips, and flounder, with tartar and cocktail sauce

Entree Salad Platters

Agenerous portion of your favorite entree served on top of fresh greens. Served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw and your favorite salad dressing. Creamy Ranch, Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette or Bleu Cheese (add 50¢)

• Marinated Char-Broiled Tuna Steak*

  • Market Price

• Marinated Char-Broiled Swordfish

  • Market Price

• Combo (Tuna and Sword)*

  • Market Price

• Broiled Jumbo Shrimp "Scampi Style"US$ 24,95

• Broiled Marinated Chicken Breast FiletUS$ 19,95

• Broiled Salmon Filet

  • Market Price

Extras

• Crispy "Crinkle-Cut" FriesUS$ 5,50

• Homemade Creamy Cole SlawUS$ 3,50

  made fresh daily, a 1/2 lb.

• Tossed SaladUS$ 6,50

  Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing.

• Sweet Corn on the CobUS$ 2,75

  local when available.

• Battered Onion RingsUS$ 9,50

  Sweet large onions fried golden brown.

• Roasted New PotatoesUS$ 5,25

  Lightly seasoned.

• Sweet Potato FriesUS$ 7,50

Nostalgic Specialty Drinks

• Chocolate Egg CreamUS$ 4,95

• Daniel's Frozen LemonadeUS$ 6,00

• Shirley TempleUS$ 2,95

• IBC Root Beer (by the bottle)US$ 2,95

• Cherry CokeUS$ 2,95

• Root Beer FloatUS$ 7,50

• Old Fashioned Malted MilkshakeUS$ 7,50

• Vanilla MilkshakeUS$ 7,50