Tellers: An American Chophouse

Went for date night. Great service. Food was good. Had the porterhouse for two, lobster Mac, creamed spinach, potatoes au gratin, and crab cakes.

Next time we would get the tomahawk steak and the filet Mignon Wellington (would like to try) would probably skip the potatoes au gratin. Also would like to get it Delmonico style. Ordered it and the waiter missed it- didn’t notice until halfway through the steak so didn’t ask to send back.

We were in and out within an hour and didn’t even notice! Was never rushed At all, we just didn’t realize how quick our service was.

Would like to try this place for lunch

Amazing experience and staff. Extremely polite. Highly recommended.

This place is my go to steakhouse for all events now. I can stop looking. If you want a great spot with wonderful food, this is it.

Teller's is top notch in food ambiance and service!

Staff were all so friendly and professional. Food and drinks were delicious ! Everything was cooked to perfection !

It took very long to get our entree

It was amazing all I can say

Nice ambience. great food!

We were there for lunch on Valentine’s Day. The wait for our food was extremely long. Due to the fact that it was a “holiday” there was no lunch menu (which was never the case in years past) so the meals we ordered were quite pricey and unfortunately we had to send back one meal. It was steak - it was tough and fatty - which shouldn’t happen at a steak house. Ambiance and our waiter were great but the experience overall was ruined by the fact that one meal was inedible.

Amazing as always! Fernando the waiter, who we’ve had a few times is always great!

Absolutely awesome as usual! Very attentive staff: waiter Chris.

The cuisine was exquisite . The staff was very welcoming , friendly , knowledgeable , and professional .
I highly recommend Tellers .

Went to teller’s for my birthday dinner, as usual the food was amazing. Our server Fernando was attentive, friendly professional and most of all gracious. He is a good asset to Tellers, he always does an outstanding job!

The food and service was excellent. My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed.

Delicious food, lively atmosphere.

Our first time going to Tellers was a wonderful experience . Though we would probably never would have gone there if we didn’t have a gift card . The service was wonderful . We decided to go for the Sunday pre fixed dinner . It was more than i expected . The food was out of this world , i was just a little taken back by the small portion of the sides that were given that was a la Carte and how costly they were . 5 dollars for a small coke was a little crazy .

It was a great experience. We had not been there before. We sat by the fireplace. The ambience was gorgeous. Food was terrific. Spent 2 hours there and there was no rush.ing to have us leave. Would go again.

Sunday early dinner at 3:15PM. We were given a choice of where to sit, which we decided on the lounge next to the bar. Very cozy area with only 6 tables, near the gas fireplace. Sunday had a $45 prix fixe menu, which was amazing! Started with Calamari, which were seasoned well and fried crispy. For dinner I had the Fish of the Day, which happened to be swordfish. It was served with hashed potatoes and lobster, in a lemon creme fraiche. The fish was cooked with a crispy outer skin, but was moist and meaty. The lemon creme fraiche really tied the whole dish together; if I could have licked the plate, I would have! For dessert I ordered cheesecake, to go, but did eat the cheesecake over the next 2 days because it was so big! Delicious in every way, with a thicker than normal graham cracker crust (my favorite part). Hubby had Lobster Bisque to start, which was good, but he would have liked to see more lobster meat in the actual bisque. He then got the Teller's Ribeye, which is 36oz of meat and bone (tomahawk). Steak was, of course, cooked perfectly, and my husband ate every last piece of meat. His meal was not on the $45 prix fixe, but the food is well worth the money spent on it.

Food was beyond excellent. When we walked in the hostess greeted us and went to set us up with our table but before she walked us over picked up the phone and talked to another customer about reservations for about 5 minutes making us wait. I thought it was rude and extremely unprofessional. Then we were seated. First ones in the restaurant. Our server was great. Ordered appetizers and WAITED AND WAITED for a long while before they were brought out. All other tables in the restaurant were finished with their appetizers before we even received ours. Hoping that this was a fluke thing that the service was extremely off because the food was excellent.

Exquisite service food drinks

It is always a special meal when you go to Tellers. Everything about it is a pleasant experience - the food is always great, the service is awesome and great ambiance. A very special place!

Great food, super service and excellent wine menu, everytime we eat at Tellers it's a treat, we have never been disappointed.

Great dinner, delicious food, excellent service!!!

I read about Teller's online and read reviews as well. We drove over an hour to get to the restaurant and it was well worth it. Food was fantastic and our server, Joseph, went above and beyond, truly. He gave my mother a $25 gift card for her birthday, and comped our desserts. We LOVED the Delmonico. 2 of us had the strip, and one person had the rib eye. Rib eye was the way to go, but both cuts were excellent. This is definitely a special occasion place due to the prices, but if you can afford it, so worth it. My fiancee and I will be back for her birthday.

Our waiter Chris C was great, he was very attentive and
Helpful with wine and food choices!

special birthday dinner - filet mignon was cooked to perfection! Always a great meal here!

Had a great dinner as always and Steve is always the best we will be back soon.

Excellent for special occasions. Steaks are cooked to perfection. Service is attentive but not imposing.
Highly recommend!

Great food, great service! Highly recommend!

Absolutely a great experience, always! The service, food, ambiance cannot be beat. We will keep coming back again & again. We have many friends who also LOVE Tellers!

Pricey but absolutely delicious! Will definitely go again!

Beautiful location with awesome first class service by professional staff. The food is made perfectly and tastes great. Very good restaurant.

Delish
Excellent service by Mike C
Chef & crew “Thsnk You”
Loved that a manager came to visit our table, had first timers with us & they were very impressed!

Didn’t realize it was restaurant week made the reservation on the Tuesday thinking we’d have a nice quiet business dinner. Staying with the prefix menu seem to confuse the staff. Haven’t been there in years and it used to be really good it was OK

Tellers is always a fine place to dine. The ambience, food and service is exceptional!

Everything a steakhouse should be. The bar was beautiful and the service was great. Food was comparable to the big one in Brooklyn.

We had yet another unbelievable meal at Tellers . Chris our server was excellent every steak came out perfect and the room was electric . we are big fans of the Bholson family restaurants .
Let’s do an exotic car show event prime or tellers

Steve our Waiter was excellent. Made our dinning experience very enjoyable. Look forward to our next visit. Thank you

Great food and atmosphere. Really enjoyed the prompt service and the delicious dinner and drinks.

Great steakhouse on Long Island! Went for my dads birthday.