Tellers: An American Chophouse

Tellers is truly a dining experience. The food and service are exceptional.

This restaurant was excellent in every aspect! Customer service was outstanding and out waiter was extremely helpful with our menu.

Kevin was an amazing server he did a great job so tentative and we appreciated all the suggestions and the service that he provided was amazing day so cute

Great spot

I don’t think there are enough compliments I can give. The service was like a well-oiled, militant ballroom dance. These servers genuinely care for sharing the love of their craft, executing fine dining in an exquisite march. Ambience, energy and elegance were the keywords of the evening. Am I overselling? No. This was the very bit of charm and delight I needed tonight. Thank you.

First time patrons. The food was terrific and the service was excellent. The menu had some interesting options, we will definitely be returning.

Very friendly atmosphere and fast good service also very clean establishment

Another wonderful lunch at Tellers with friend! Every single time i go, Adam, our waiter, makes us feel like celebrities. He makes one of most favorite evening dining just as special for lunch! Thank you to all there who make lunch just as special as dinner!

Dinner was amazing we did the wine pairing everything was great!

Tellers is ALWAYS EXCELLENT. Monsoon is always garbage, I can’t believe it’s the same owners.

The prime rib was beyond perfect! Salty and delicious! Shrimp and lobster wontons were light, airy and crispy. Lisa, our waitress was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. Great place!

Above par service and food every single time. I’ve never had a better dining experience!

We've dined at Teller's at least once or twice a year since the restaurant opened. Usually on Saturday nights, when there is a lot of energy in the dining rooms. We are unabashed fans of the restaurant - it is consistently good and a very enjoyable place to go. This time, we went the night after Thanksgiving, and while the food was good, the energy seemed gone from the restaurant. This time we found the background music loud and somewhat annoying and not really what we associate with a "classy" restaurant - but we are getting older and are somewhat conservative in our dining-out tastes, so keep that in mind. Our waitress, Lissette was really very good, friendly and reasonably attentive. So I'm giving a rating of "Very Good" although I generally think of this restaurant as Outstanding.

amazing place to take my girlfriend for her birthday. the gold bar section was amazing.

Just had my birthday dinner at Tellers
Usually love this place
Disappointed tonight over and over
Lobster bisque was Luke warm and we got served soup and took much time till we could find someone to ask for spoons to eat!!!!!!
Got over cooked skirt steak which was hard to cut and hard to chew and overly soaked in marinade, over cooked and slightly burnt tater tots, scalloped potatoes didn’t seem freshly made, cheesecake somewhat stale and not light and smooth, very thick tasting, berries with it sour, was not presented in a large enough dish, my birthday was not acknowledged in any way and I told the girls when I entered the restaurant, and wrote it in open table and then a gift card came after I reminded the waiter
I had just eaten here a week and a half ago so I was so with this below average food and service
Oh forgot to mention I had to wait and ask for a knife to cut my steak
Overpriced meal for what we ate and the service

Wonderful service and the food is very delicious. My guests were always very happy with the atmosphere and the meal.

Stunning ambiance, and five star food with a twist, in exotic presentations always! M y family owned a restaurant for 28 years featuring authentic Italian and Mediterranean foods from southern and northern Italy, so I am " annoyingly discerning " about cuisine. Tellers tops my go to list always. Keep those chefs!

the tellers delmonico steak is always a great and so is the half chicken very tasty....
the chopped salad is our favorite along with the baked clams.
A wonderful evening with fsmily.

Food was eh. For the price wasn’t up to par

We had dinner there as a birthday celebration. We had advised them in advance through open table. The hostess was aware and wished me a happy birthday. The policy of Tellers is to provide a dessert and small gift card to patrons dining on their birthday. We received neither.

The food was good but really not special as the pricing should warrant. We also were there for only an hour which included seating order taking the check and a three course meal. We felt rushed as each course came on the heals of the last.

A restaurant where the cost per person is between $50-$100 should provide a special experience. Sadly Tellers did not.

First of all...you made a mistake. My reservation was for 3 o'clock, not 5. Next...it was very cold at Tellers and others along with us asked to have the ac turned off. It was 45 degrees outside. Could not enjoy anything because we were freezing for over 2 hours. The food was okay and over priced. Our waiter, Kevin was great.

We had a 8:45 reservation and was taken to our table at 9:30. There was literally no room to stand at the bar so we waited on he outskirts.
When we got to our table there was an obnoxiously loud group. For the money you’re paying- you would think the servers would have said something to them. My husband and I couldn’t even hold a conversation because we couldn’t hear each other.
The food was excellent, but the noise level really ruined our experience.

Food was great, hospitality great, definitely loud but can be expected. Made a reservation but waited 45 minutes which I’m not happy about.

Great meal and service as always.

Just went here for the 1st time and the food was good, waitress was great but what spoiled the beginning part of the evening was that we had a 7:30 reservation and we did not sit until 8:40. We were annoyed and a little Hangry. The food was good, what I expected.

We love Teller. Food is always amazing and the service is impeccable!

My husband and I totally enjoyed our night out at Teller's. The food was superb and the wait staff was very attentive and conscientious. All in all, it was a perfect date night for us!

Awesome as always! The food, and the service can't be beat.

I thought the branzino was delicious and my daughter enjoyed her filet mignon. The whipped potatoes were flat, tasteless and gooey and not whipped. I should have sent them back. The dishes needed a garnish or something besides just main meal. Too stark. Loved the Irish coffee desert and the waiter was MIA most of the time. It was a hit or miss kind of meal but I would go back and try it again.

John was great, food was perfect from appetizer to dessert. New favorite place. Special for the night was swordfish. It was perfect

Nice night out. We started in the bar area which is really a beautiful spot. Classic wood décor, fireplace, etc. We moved to the dining room which is nice but somewhat ordinary. The food was excellent but the service was lacking. We enjoy Bohlsen restaurants often and we always note that the service is very efficient, friendly, and they always seem to want you to really enjoy yourself. (This is especially true at H2O in Smithtown). This somewhat busy Friday night was unfortunately an exception.

I hate to sound like a nitpicker, but when you go to a high end steakhouse you expect things like bread plates, and separate plates on which to share appetizers. The shared appetizers came out at the same time as the salads and the salad eaters needed to put their appetizers on their dressing soaked salad plates. Yikes, I do sound like a nitpicker! But the point is, the service was lacking in many ways. That was one example.

The food was all excellent. We loved the tuna tartar appetizer, which was a generous portion of chunks of fresh delicious tuna with some ridiculously good concoction to dip it in. We also had the seared scallops which were excellent and the brisket risotto which wasn't as good as it sounds. We all had filets for dinner which were all perfectly cooked to our liking and well seasoned. Very good. The mac and cheese was decadent and delicious...Brussel sprouts and the massive homemade tater tots were also very good.

Incredibly disappointing experience. I would have to say the kitchen has given up. Our waiter Steve was very friendly but nothing we received was hot, warm at best. Appetizers of crab wanton and risotto were the high point of the evening by far, although the risotto arrived warm at best. My $54 prime rib, promised with horseradish source and two sides was delivered cold. I guess each slice of wilted spinach stood for a side. The horseradish sauce was the most disappointing, at least the chef bothered to take the plastic cover off after removing it from the refrigerator, cold as a rock. My fiancé’s microscopic piece of swordfish was cold as well. Has the chef every thought to use a seasoning other than salt on the prime rib? At $211, the meal was the most unimpressive one I have had this year. I’m sure there are still a few restaurants that care about their customers, this definitely is not one of them. Save your money and find one. BTW, the customers on both sides of our table had similar experiences. The couple to me left received their sides without serving spoons, how is that even possible? Their uneaten steak for two said it all. I’m sure many customers and their dogs woke up both unimpressed with last night’s experience and will not be returning either . What a shame !

I went to Tellers for the first time on Monday and was pleasantly surprised. My friend had been telling me about the place for quite a while but I had no idea how delicious it would be. The lobster mac and cheese was on point and the filet mignon Wellington was beyond tender. I highly recommend Tellers for a special night out.

Absolutely love this restaurant... from the deliciousness of the food to the specialness of service. Another wonderful experience at Tellers this evening. Our waiter Chris was outstanding!

Usually frequent Prime but they have nothing on their sister restaurant Tellers . Awesome experience and service is second to none . Plus the restaurant week menu was awesome !

Excellent food and service

Great steaks excellent service. A great dinning experience. Looking forward to going back.

Great food Great service
Steve is an excellent waiter!!!
Can’t wait to go back!!!

food was outstanding.. noise level was a bit high , service by Mike was excellent....pricey but worth it

Recently had a anniversary there with family. The food was excellent. Standouts were the 40 oz. rib eye lobster mac and cheese and the fries made in duck fat. I can feel my arteries closing as i am writing this. What the hell you only live once. Anyway the place is very nice and the service is excellent. Thank you for a lovely meal