Service was excellent, The food was ok-good, i don't think it was worth the price. I've had steaks that were just as good in other places for, ( filet migion) alot cheaper, the sauted spinach was too garlicy, could have used more butter and salt. but our waiter was terrific, young man was quit a gentleman!!

Excellent all around

Excellent choice for fine dining and a for a night out.

another amazing night at Teller's. Food was exceptional and the service was outstanding

Outstanding food and service. We very much look forward to another visit.

Our server, although polite, seemed to be in a rush every time he came to our table. We greatly enjoyed the food and drinks. Will continue to visit.

The atmosphere was great as always. All of the food came out perfectly. Will definitely be back.

25th anniversary and Tellers made it spectacular!!!!!! Food and service was incredible!!!!!!

Omg i loved this place a little pricey but so worth it, staff was wonderful & atmosphere was great ! would deff recommend ! (:

Great night out even in times of Covid 19! Excellent food 😋 and service

Excellent food, atmosphere, and service, will come back in future

Absolutely superb dining experience. Our waiter Will was very attentive and knowledgeable. The food was excellent we weren’t rushed to leave. Will be back soon!

Food wasn’t very impressive for the amount of money it costs to dine here. I’ve been here before and it’s been great, hoping it was just off because of the current conditions. Service was great as usual. And manager even took an item off the bill, even though we insisted he didn’t.

We have been to Tellers a few times, and every subsequent time has been better than the last. During these tough times, it was nice that they’ve been able to adapt, and not sacrifice the quality of service and the cuisine. We arrived minutes before our reservation and they sat as right away. The staff was adhering to the safety guidelines and the outdoor setup was conducive to a socially distant dining experience. Our server, Chris, was friendly and attentive. The Delmonico that my wife ordered was cooked to perfection. My Wellington was a perfect medium rare, with a golden, flaky crust. The mushroom duxelles and the Brie fondue was a perfect compliment for my dish. Asparagus and Five Cheese Mac & Cheese rounded out our perfect meals and left us so full, there was no room for dessert, sadly. Overall, an excellent meal/dining experience that we cannot wait to do again!

Great dinning experience. We both had the black lable burgers. Dennis gave us a Booth table which was very nice. Look forward to our next visit.

Great service, food was delish.

Efficient service and polite staff. Very good food.

Birthday dinner, great steaks and service

Everything was phenomenal except we ate outside and there were a few bees, not a complaint just a fact of life.

We went to Tellers for my daughter's graduation celebration. The server was amazing. The outdoor dining was beautifully set up. I will definitely be returning.

Seafood tower was fresh and delicious. The oysters, shrimp, & baked clams are highly recommended.

They’re still having difficulty with the doneness of their steaks. My guest and I both had to send them back to bring them to medium rare. Once cooked to the correct temperature they were fantastic, but we’d like for them to get it right the first time around.

The best steaks on long island and great service.

Went for our 20th Anniversary..Sat outside..Beautiful ambience, delicious food and drinks..Service was excellent! Bit pricey but delicious!!

So lovely sitting outside in the fresh breezy air. Deliciously prepared salmon over excellent veggie hash, and expertly served. We felt like we were on vacation. It was a welcome respite from the daily pandemic existence. We felt special.

Lisa was an amazing server. Lauren was wonderful and made a great night out even better

First time at Tellers and will absolutely return. Food and drinks were phenomenal but the service by the staff was world class. Highly recommend.

Great service!! Amazing food!

Food was amazing. Service was amazing, our server Keith was absolutely amazing, very attentive. 10/10 will visit again.

Everything at Teller’s was amazing! Great service, delicious food, nice ambiance and atmosphere! Our server Chelsea was super sweet and made sure we enjoyed our experience. Lauren, one of the managers was also so so nice and gave us excellent service as well. We went for my boyfriend’s birthday and they went above and beyond, $25 gift-card to use next time and a complimentary dessert to take home! Thank you so much Teller’s! We will definitely be back soon!!

First experience post quarantine with eating at a restaurant. We dined outdoors. Felt completely safe and they service and food was outstanding as usual.

Celebrated my birthday there. Food was excellent. Service was great. Definitely will return. They gave me a $25 gift card for birthday to use on my next visit.

Teller’s is an outstanding restaurant. Everything is great and the burgers are unbelievable. Service is second to none! You can not go wrong at Teller’s.

Outdoor dining at Tellers was reminiscent of eating at a European café, but with awesome American steak and salmon! Service and food were both outstanding! The prix-fixe lunch is a wonderful value as well!

Excellent service! Food was cooked to perfection. It’s very expensive.

Our waiter was amazing! We love Teller’s and today’s lunch experience did not disappoint.

Excellent food and service!

Excellent and safe- felt safe.

great lunch menu, service was outstanding< We will definitely be back!

Crazy times but this was a great outdoor experience.

We had a great time food was amazing and our
waitress was so nice