Always perfect. Never a bad meal. Steak is cooked exactly how you order it

Great Food and Service as always...

All was very good to excellent, waiter was very good, winelist was good

Teller's always is reliable. The food is of high quality and the service very attentive. Their special luncheon is extremely reasonable priced. I had an excellent bowl of lobster bisque, a plentiful lobster roll and a very large order of French fries for either 20 or 21$. I particularly like lobster bisque and Teller's is among the best in the region.

Great night out with some good friends.
Excellent service by Joe & Nemo

We were there for their anniversary special menu and were pleasantly surprised by the size of the portions and selections for the Fixed Price event! The wine pairing was also quite good. Our waiter was attentive, informative and friendly. We will visit again!

From the unbelievably tasty and clean oysters, to the perfect filet on the bone (cooked perfectly medium rare), it was a great experience. The chocolate & peanut butter parfait was off the charts great!

Another excellent meal at Tellers! Enjoyed their 19th anniversary dinner selection (Caesar salad and beef wellington for $40). Well worth it; our waiter Willie was terrific.

We went for the 19th Anniversary Pre-fix. It was a GREAT deal. It was plenty of food for a great price. We had been wanting to try Tellers, but were told by several friends it is not worth the $. We all know Steak houses are pricey. We don’t mind the splurge for a great meal. This was not a great meal, it was good. The atmosphere was GREAT! Beautiful decor and authentic! I would love to see it at Christmas. The service was very good also. The food was underwhelming. We are very glad we didn’t spend a lot on going there. We are glad we went, but won’t be back.

Great place never disappointed at TELLERS

My 2nd visit to Tellers in last few months, 1st time was a birthday lunch and last night was dinner with my wife. Both times the food and service was excellent, will be back soon!

Excellent service. Very accommodating. Food is always consistent and on point. Love it there.

Great food and service. Wish tables were not so close

Steak was raw, wine was diluted, waitress never delivered appetizer and her response was “ now you will have room for dessert”. service was sloooooow. Wine was unlimited but every time we asked for a refill, she would forget.... Will not be back.

This is the third year in a row we have celebrated our daughter's birthday at Tellers. We have never been disappointed! They honor reservations and are prompt at seating their guests. The Anniversary special is always a plus if we don't order from the regular menu.
Filet mignon was perfectly cooked and the lobster tails were delicious!
We will certainly return to Teller's for dinner

Tellers never disappoints. The food is amazing. The service is wonderful.

Another great meal, all worked so well

I loved everthing. The service was exceptional. The veal chop delicious.

A little pricey but fine for a special occasion. Food was excellent. Room kept a bit too cool but otherwise a nice experience.

Our waiter recommended the $19 Prix Fixe Menu and I also added on the $10 wine pairing. It was a great value and the food was delicious. I was impressed by how attentive the waitstaff was (I was given my second glass of wine as soon as I finished the first). Dirty dishes were cleared away immediately and we didn't feel pressured to order dessert (although we did after hearing about the homemade ice cream). Teller's exceeded my expectations. I would definitely go again.

Our family took out my sister in law for her birthday. Customer service is excellent anything we needed our server was right there with a smile. All the food was very good and little pricey but it’s worth it. The staff went above and beyond to make my sister laws birthday a good experience with out asking. Over all if you like being treated like royalty this is the place to go.

Love this restaurant, have eaten here many times and the food never disappoints.

We really enjoyed our meals & desserts. The waiter Willy was super! and we loved the story behind the old bank building.
The noise level was a bit high in the upstairs after about 1/2 of our reservation. Would like to see the upstairs a bit brighter: the lighting and color was too dark,and maybe flowers on the table. Should be alerted about the stairs when you book the reservation. The stairs were tricky and could have been a problem with our elderly guest. We want to sit downstairs next time because we loved the look of the downstairs room: the brighter, lighter color and the high ceiling made it looked quite grand.
Thank you for treating us all so special on our celebration evening!

For me, this is the top steakhouse on LI. Everything prepared well, great service and great setting .
Weekend prime rib to die for!

Another great lunch at Tellers. Lobster Bisque is always good. Calamari was disappointing. Branzino and Salmon were delicious. Coffee was good. A very good lunch.

Great service. The food was AMAZING! highly recommend

Excellent food and service!

Excellent food and service, as always. Peter Lugers has nothing on this place.

Another great dining experience at Tellers! Celebrated my husband's 65th and son-in-laws 30th Birthdays and we could not have made a better choice. Love Tellers!

we were seated immediately, Kevin our server and his staff were very attentive, always keeping our sparkling waters full. food was delicious and steaks cooked perfectly. Just a hint:
review the steak temperatures with the server, Tellers is not the same as other steak houses, if you like medium order medium well at Tellers, it will be perfect!

Steve our server was awesome and Miguel from Palmer for the wine dinner was great 👍🍷

The food was excellent and the service was great. The only negative was that the tables were very close to one another.

The Best Bartender Around. The food is great. Bring your wallet.

Excellent as always

Under normal circumstances I would have given this restaurant 5 stars across the board. We have been to Tellers many times and it has never disappointed...until now. We had 8pm reservations but they didn't seat us until 8:30. Never had that happen in the past. Then they sent us upstairs to a tiny dining room up a steep flight of stairs. Normally I don't care about stairs but I was wearing very high heels and felt like I was going to take a tumble the entire way up. I never knew they had an upstairs dining room. Had I known that I would have requested a table in the main dining room. I like to people watch and be a part of the what's going on but felt like I was banished upstairs. The table was stuck in a corner booth by a wall that jutted out and made it very uncomfortable. Then we ordered our usual bone-in ribeye's and a couple of side dishes and it took an hour to get served. Everyone that came in after us was served before us. Their explanation was that our steaks are thick and take a while to cook. I've had many a bone-in ribeye at Tellers, Prime and other steak houses and never had to anywhere near that long for our meal. Then to top it off they bring our food and my steak was practically raw inside. It was so stringy that I couldn't cut it. A ribeye is fatty so it should cut like butter. Obviously they rushed it out of the kitchen. I sent it back and they finally got it right. By then it was 10pm and I wasn't hungry anymore and ended up taking the whole meal home. I don't know if this was an isolated incident but I am now not so sure I want to go back. A $300 dinner for two should be impeccable and this was just a disaster from the start. I will say that the waiter and manager tried to make it up to us by giving us dessert on the house which was nice but didn't really make up for the bust of a birthday dinner. It's sad because Tellers has always been our go-to place for special occasions and now we feel like we have to pick another restaurant.

Second time to Tellers, it was fantastic again. Sat upstairs this time, different meal, different server and was great like our first time. Outstanding steaks.

First date

It was for my husband’s Birthday....we go here every year for the last ( at least) 13 year

Wonderful lunch with an extraordinarily wonderful prix Fox lunch menu which was extremely impressive to my old, childhood girlfriend, who doesn’t have such fine lunches much. Our waiter and staff could not have been more wonderful to us while dining outside on a beautiful sunny afternoon. Thanks to all. Wonderful lunch.

I have not been here for at least a year. just been too busy. The establishment has not changed a bit. Every aspect of the restaurant is very professional. The staff is very affable and accommodating. Our waiter, Chris was very professional - but not stuffy! The food - 3 Branzino dishes were excellent. The meat dishes were equally as good. Very pleasurable experience, just as I had the last time I was here!