Tellers: An American Chophouse

Excellent steaks. Great service. Well priced menu. Our favorite restaurant. Will dinner here 4 or 5 times before year ends. Thanks for the great experience.

Food was excellent as always - fantastic steaks. Service was very good but not up to the same high level of service that is normal. Ambiance was ruined by horrible disco and 80s dance music played far too loud. Wrong type of music for a fine dining restaurant with white tablecloths. It was my 80-year old father's birthday dinner and it was somewhat ruined by the obnoxious music - he loves eating at Tellers but said he is never going back because of how the loud terrible music ruined the evening.

It was an excellent night. Food and service were outstanding.

we celebrated my daughters 23rd anniversary. the staff was amazing. my daughter enjoyed immensely the cosmopolitans that the bartender Amanda made. they brought a special dessert with a candle and in chocolate Happy Anniversary. The steaks were all done to each of our requests. The creamed spinach and asparagus were done to perfection.

Service was outstanding. Our server, Lisa, went out of her way to make our evening one to remember. It was my husband's birthday and she sent out an amazing array of desserts. She was very professional and caring. Our steaks were cooked perfectly. We will be back.

Phenomenal

Perhaps the choice of music was a little out of place. I love rock but maybe something less energetic, maybe bossanova or something like it. In my humble opinion.

Anniversary

Medium steak was raw. Noisy. Arrogant staff. Will not return.

The staff far exceeded our expectations. The food was absolutely delicious. The atmosphere is exceptional and everyone there bends over backwards to make sure you are pleased with the service and the food. Teller's has gained 4 new customers and fans. We will highly recommend this restaurant to all of our friends.

The food was outstanding! The service was great! Will definitely go back again!

Again great great great, best lunch on long Island and one of the best in the world

The food is always consistently good but the staff at this restaurant are all rockstars. Every time I come back I’m reminded of the countless great experiences I’ve had with all the bartenders and waiters/waitresses. Can’t wait to come back.

Another outstanding dining experience from our special occasion go-to restaurant.

Everything about tellers is amazing, you will not be disappointed.

Always a outstanding experience. If you want a fantastic meal With a great atmosphere that is consistent day in and day out this is the place.

Great evening sitting in the lounge. A little loud but was just the influence of the bar crowd.
Enjoyed our table and the service.

Food was excellent we started off with the lobster wontons and calamari the meals included filet mignon and seared tuna everything was delicious. Side dish of lobster macaroni and cheese was amazing. Waiter and maitre d were very accommodating they even bought out a free dessert for my daughter's birthday

Great steak, cocktails. Old bank convert to restaurant with high ceilings and large windows. Welcoming bar with never ending selection of cocktails.

Excellent food and drinks! Highly recommend - definitely pricey, but worth it!

Thea best steakhouse in Long Island

We have always liked Teller’s and still do. The service and food are outstanding .Someone in our party was celebrating their birthday and they ended our meal with a nice touch.

First time at Tellers. My daughter took me for my birthday. it was her first time as well. The service was great. The staff was very helpful. A very enjoyable experience. Would recommend to friends & family.

Tellers is a favorite. From Start to finish it’s always fantastic. Best lunch in the neighborhood

Just a delicious, great night out - fab food and ambiance!

Again another great meal!!!

Another fabulous meal at Tellers. Great house Chianti. Good baked clams and lobster bisque. Good burger and very good French Dip. Excellent Service. I brought my friend for her birthday, and they generously gave her a $25 gift card. I love Teller’s.💞

Many dishes came out cold. $400 for 3 people and the good is not that great. Had Filet Mignon, veal chop, branzino, scallops, calamari app. Lobster macaroni and cheese, Burnt broccoli. The best things were the broccoli and dessert which was cream brûlée. Was here 10 years ago and didn’t like it, nothing changed! So many better places to go!

Celebrated a recent birthday at Teller's and was thoroughly pleased with the service, drinks and food. We hadn't been here in several years and decided we must come more often! They have a fantastic prix fixe menu on Tuesdays, very reasonable and delicious.

Been here numerous times, must say this was one of their best efforts. Service was slight off but still acceptable. Bacon appetizer is off the charts. Caesar salad was better than ever. Bone in filet mignon was a touch over cooked but still wonderful. Scalloped potatoes were the best I ever had. All of us enjoyed immensely. This is the the best steakhouse on the south shore for certain. Yes, it’s pricy but worth it.

The beef Wellington was amazing! It's the first time I've had it and it is a dish that I would go back for and order again. I also tried the lobster bisque - light and full of flavor. Chocolate cake for dessert was rich and
enough to share between 3 people! Our waiter was very friendly and informative. It is expensive but definitely worth a visit for a special occasion.

My only gripe was the waiter. We asked for an appetizer and he retorted in a muffled smug tone: it's better to wait until you order everything. Now even if that's the true, keep it to yourself. Yes me to death. This is an upper class dining experience. I don't expect attitude. He must've picked up on my dissatisfaction, because the appetizer came out quickly and he became very attentive and smiley. Half way through the meal any feeling of dissatisfaction was wiped away by an excellent meal and smoked bourbon. The bill was under $200, 20% gratuity and all. Well worth the meal, drinks and ambiance. I usually come here every year or so. After the experience me and my wife had I'm thinking it maybe every month or so.

Date night for our wedding Anniversary. Lovely quiet dinner with excellent service and meal.

Had porterhouse for two was undercooked and had no flavor definitely was not worth 108.00 dollers and drinks were also overpriced

Had the 12 oz filet and it was cooked to perfection. The burnt broccoli was fantastic and to top off a great evening our waiter brought us a free dessert and a $25.00 gift card because we were celebrating a birthday. Highly recommended!

Fantastic as usual Steve was the best

Staff is very accommodating and attentive

It was ok. For the price I wouldn’t go here again though, Insignia and Jedediah Hawkins have better quality food. The flavor of the lamb was good, but it was so fatty. The Brussel sprouts were plain with minimal pancetta. My husbands Waygu was very fatty as well, I know Waygu is a fatty piece of meat but if cooked right the fat should melt away leaving a deliciously tender piece of meat, again flavor was good but not quality. Asparagus was charred too much. Sweet potatoe brûlée was nothing special. For a $300 meal I shouldn’t have left hungry. BUT I will say the server Chris was attentive and knowledgeable regarding allergen information. They also did a little something special for my husbands birthday with I thought was nice - free dessert and $25 gift card.

Excellent Steaks. Better than Ruth Chris and Capital Grill.

30th bday for my firstborn!